Frequently Bought Together
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Product details
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
Customer Reviews
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
35 of 36 people found the following review helpful
This is basically the Laughing Man Story from Stand Alone Complex season 1 edited down to a feature length movie with extra scenes. in Japan there's also a DVD foro the Individual 11 story for the second season, so don't buy this expecting to see a brand new story about The Laughing Man. I got this because I'm a die hard collector of Ghost In The Shell memorabillia.
I only give it 3 stars due to it's lack of new content :)
I only give it 3 stars due to it's lack of new content :)
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful
I don't usually review anything, but I am a massive fan of the Ghost in the Shell series and wanted to make sure people know not to watch this dvd if you haven't seen the original Stand Alone Complex series. By all means get it and watch it once you have seen the first GIG, but this dvd is - like previously mentioned by other reviewers - for die hard fans only. If you can't afford the original series.... keep saving! Trust me - it's worth it! (in fact the whole series on amazon is not much more than this dvd)
I was aware this was going to be similar, but wasn't sure if it was going to be like an OVA. t's the same scenes editied from the original to put all the laughing man story in one feature length story - and dubbing completely re-recorded with a new cast.
The first series to me is still one of the most incredible I have seen and touches so many issues and scenarios that could well be something possible in a future age. The first series, where its main focus is the laughing man case, includes random stories that may not always have anything to do with the laughing man, but add to your understanding of the world of cyberisation and how and why characters have developed through the series.
This dvd, where it does not lose much content of the actual laughing man story - I feel that there are parts a new viewer may find either unexplained, random or convienient. Obviously they have changed some dialog to make it more feasible, but it doesn't feel as sharp as the original series.
The voice acting - as I totally agree with another reviewer - was nowhere near as good as the usual crew. I found it irritating that the new cast sounded to me like the original cast re-recorded the whole thing whilst pinching their noses to make a nasal sound (although I am biased - the original crew on this series still to me have done the best dubbing I have seen on an Anime. There are other animes where I wont watch the dub as it is just too hurrendous). The Chief's voice is terrible - Togusa and Batou just sound like young arrogant teens, and although the voice of Kusenagi does well - she's definately still no Mary McGlynn
Please don't let this put you off of the GiTS series in anyway, mangas, films, series, music, novels - it's all fantastic - just make sure you watch it after the first series
The story of the laughing man easily gets 5 stars
This dvd gets 2 stars for nothing new in story and sub-par voice actors
I was aware this was going to be similar, but wasn't sure if it was going to be like an OVA. t's the same scenes editied from the original to put all the laughing man story in one feature length story - and dubbing completely re-recorded with a new cast.
The first series to me is still one of the most incredible I have seen and touches so many issues and scenarios that could well be something possible in a future age. The first series, where its main focus is the laughing man case, includes random stories that may not always have anything to do with the laughing man, but add to your understanding of the world of cyberisation and how and why characters have developed through the series.
This dvd, where it does not lose much content of the actual laughing man story - I feel that there are parts a new viewer may find either unexplained, random or convienient. Obviously they have changed some dialog to make it more feasible, but it doesn't feel as sharp as the original series.
The voice acting - as I totally agree with another reviewer - was nowhere near as good as the usual crew. I found it irritating that the new cast sounded to me like the original cast re-recorded the whole thing whilst pinching their noses to make a nasal sound (although I am biased - the original crew on this series still to me have done the best dubbing I have seen on an Anime. There are other animes where I wont watch the dub as it is just too hurrendous). The Chief's voice is terrible - Togusa and Batou just sound like young arrogant teens, and although the voice of Kusenagi does well - she's definately still no Mary McGlynn
Please don't let this put you off of the GiTS series in anyway, mangas, films, series, music, novels - it's all fantastic - just make sure you watch it after the first series
The story of the laughing man easily gets 5 stars
This dvd gets 2 stars for nothing new in story and sub-par voice actors
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful
This is a good dvd for the amount you pay for it and in general is a very good introduction into the ghost in the shell series. the reason i gave it 2 stars was because they have changed the voice actors from the original. something may i add that bandai seem to love to do for reasons i dont know why. Anyways some of the voice actors are okay the voice for the Major was pretty good not as good as the original but the actor had talent. however the voice for the chief is horrible and it made me cringe every time his scenes came up he sounds nothing like the bad ass chief i know from the series but more like a kid with a croaky voice. all in all id say Buy this if your new to the series and cant afford or get the originals or buy it just to be able to say you own all the dvds. otherwise forget about it as its definately a below average dvd for a Ghost in the shell.
Most Recent Customer Reviews
Excellent, however......
GHOST IN THE SHELL - THE LAUGHING MAN REVIEW
Firstly I have to say it, both this movie and it's first installment 'The Laughing Man', are entire seasons cut down and... Read more
Firstly I have to say it, both this movie and it's first installment 'The Laughing Man', are entire seasons cut down and... Read more
Published 4 months ago by Sean Curtin
Great show but buy the full series 1 boxset
This edited summary of the Series 1 boxset is inferior in every way and especially in the soundtrack department. Read more
Published on 1 May 2008 by timlondon02
Customer Discussions
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|
Listmania!
|
|
Look for similar items by category
Look for similar items by subject
Feedback
- Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
