Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Definitive..., 14 Sep 2005
Although Geoff Boycott himself needs no introduction, many of the aspects of both his career, and his personal life have been either lost or exaggerated in the plethora of tales and anecdotes about his life. Leo McKinstry aims to set the record straight in this frank and incredibly well-researched biography.He succeeds emphatically, cutting through all the tabloid hysteria that surrounded Boycott's life, and delivering a brilliant and, most importantly, honest portrayal of one of sport's most complex individuals. The story itself is as compelling as any biography I have read, and is by far and away the most definitve and complete book about Boycott. Whatever anyone's personal view of Boycott, one cannot help but be gripped by the incredible single-mindedness and tenacity of the man who 'just wanted to play cricket for Yorkshire'. It truly is a most remarkable read, and moves at such a spanking pace it could almost be a novel. I read this book in one sitting, and anybody who has even a passing interest in cricket should certainly pick this one up. At this price there is absolutely no reason not to.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A very fair account - which is what matters in this case, 18 Jun 2007
Boycott evokes strong responses in many people on both sides of the fence: amongst professional cricketers past and present, amongst cricket fans and amongst the general public by dint of his wider celebrity. Those views are deeply entrenched and, I suspect, unlikely to be changed. If you retain an open mind however then, simply, there's no better place to look to form your opinion on Boycs than Leo McKinstry's excellent biography.
The subtitle of the book, 'A cricketing hero' kind of hints at McKinstry's personal stance on Boycott (indeed, it would a strange author indeed who took the trouble to write a biography on a cricketer s/he despised....which makes me wonder about Don Mosey...) but the overwhelming impression I got from the biography was just how fair it was: McKinstry is obviously an admirer of, but by no means an apologist for, Boycott.
Most of the prejudices, misconceptions and lazy tabloid thumbnails of Boycott - received wisdom built upon professional jealousies, Chinese whispers and apocryphal gossip - are expertly picked apart with logic and bare facts. Many of the anecdotes exposing Boycott's boorishness, arrogance, selfishness and social ineptitude are upheld, with no attempt to excuse, contextualise or qualify them.
With admirably comprehensive research and careful and even-handed compilation, Boycott is presented as a very complex character, a person of stark contradictions: utterly self-centred but also generous, eye-wateringly rude and insensitive and yet considerate and charming, confident, calculating and determined whilst also emotionally fragile and in need of constant encouragement, intensely private but craving attention.
I have read more passionate and interesting cricketing [auto]biographies but, given the aim of the book, none have been better researched or well balanced.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The best cricket biography I have read, 14 Aug 2006
Geoffrey Boycott : A Cricketing Hero is a crickting biography that impressed me the most about books of cricketing legends I have read so far to emerge in the scene. It is beatifully and insightfully written to paint a full picture of Boycott from various angles. The main features include childhood, schooling days, first cricket career, international scene, media role, continued contribution to the game and personal life. He unfortunately is no stranger to controversy as few parts of the book provide evidence of.
Geoffrey Boycott is clearly misunderstood as it an initial impression that I potray of the legend. A few distinguish traits are not favoured well with peers. He is perceived as self centred, obsessed and arrogant individual, but no one can deny he is one of the all time cricketing greats to embrace a name within the sport. He loves and is passionate about cricket, which is unquestionable. Ok he resorts to quarrels with the management and is obsessive with technique, but their is real truth to this. The author sets about trying to understand Boycott's character and looks at contrasting sides the personality.
If you have a passion for cricket, read this biography and you will understand the psychology of Geoffrey Boycott's personality and what traits differniates the legend from leading cricketers. The biography is beautifully narrated and colourfully in sighted. It took me three days to read this biography, as it is so fascinating and interesting.
|
|
|
|