It's been a long time coming, but Karnataka's latest - their first with the new line-up following the dissolution of the original line-up back in 2004 - really has surpassed my wildest expectations. They performed the majority of this material on their Autumn 2008 tour, and it was impressive then, but clearly the material has benefited from the extra time in the studio. The album is beautifully produced despite a very dense and highly arranged sound: this is powerful and emotive symphonic rock without a hint of the excess that usually accompanies the term.
"The Gathering Light" sees the new-look Karnataka stretching out in a slightly more progressive direction, with several tracks running to ten minutes or more in length. There is, however, no flabby excess here - even when the songs contain lengthy instrumental sections, repetition is kept to a minimum and the results are extremely melodic. Indeed guitarist Enrico Pinna is a particular star throughout: his roots lie in jazz, but here he has risen admirably to the challenge posed by such dense material, providing a virtuoso performance of David Gilmour-esque proportions. His solo on "Forsaken" is set to become a classic progressive rock "moment".
The real question for many fans is whether new vocalist Lisa Fury can live up to the legacy of her predecessor, Rachel Jones. Happily, the answer is a resounding yes. Lisa possesses a more versatile and rock-oriented voice, equally at home on billowing ballads like "Moment In Time" and "Forsaken" as it is on chunky rockers like "Your World" and "Tide To Fall". Her crystal-clear vocals mirror accomplished performers such as Julianne Regan, Judie Tzuke and Moya Brennan; effortlessly emotive and with an impressive range, Lisa delivers a virtually perfect performance. Against all the odds, it would seem that Karnataka's lynchpin, bassist Ian Jones, has found the ideal vocalist for the band.
This is an exceptionally strong album, even for a band as reliable as Karnataka, and it would seem, based on the string of rave reviews the album has already received both in the press and online, that I'm far from alone in thinking that they may just have served up their best work to date.