The best American journalism can stand comparison with any. Game Change is about as good as it gets - in the tradition of All The President's Men.
This is a blow-by-blow, almost day-by-day account of the 2008 US Presidential election, from the battle for nomination right up to the doors of the White House. Of course, we know from the outset how it will end but that gives the book its architecture. What is fascinating is the uncovering of the foundations, the bricks, the plaster, above all the emotion and the drama of the days when this or that edifice - Obama or Clinton, Obama or McCain - almost comes tumbling down, until at last one does. The race is starkly winner-takes-all, though in Hillary Clinton's case there is a substantial consolation prize.
The reviewer who raises an eyebrow at "unsubstantiated hearsay" may have skipped the Authors' Note. This makes clear that the basis for the book was "more than three hundred interviews with more than two hundred people ... in sessions that often stretched over several hours." Reasons for the authenticity of quoted dialogue are set out in detail. Certain thoughts or feelings are characterised by the use of italics. This is serious and responsible journalism. If Obama inevitably emerges as the hero, he does not do so free from criticism.
By the end, the reader will know what it was like in intimate detail for all the participants, major and minor. This is one of those rare volumes for which five stars seem inadequate.