Four-Dimensionalism: An Ontology of Persistence and Time
and over one million other books are available for Amazon Kindle .
Learn more
| ||||||||||||||||||||
 Trade In this Item for up to £7.05
Trade in Four-Dimensionalism: An Ontology of Persistence and Time (Mind Association Occasional Series) for an Amazon.co.uk gift card of up to £7.05, which you can then spend on millions of items across the site. Plus, get an extra £5 when you trade in books worth £10 or more until June 30, 2012. Trade-in values may vary (terms apply). Find more products eligible for trade-in.
|
Frequently Bought Together
Product details
|
More About the Author
Product Description
Review
For many years to come, this is sure to be the locus classicus with respect to which all those engaged with the literature on persistence must position themselves. (Kathrin Koslicki, Philosophical Review )
This is simply a superb book in metaphysics - handsomely written, cleverly argued, and exceedingly clear. (Hud Hudson, Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews )
Sider does not deny that this four-dimensionalist conception of persisting things is counterintuitive. His claim is that, all things considered, it yields a more coherent ontology than any of its competitors. His defence of this claim is impressive: bold, clear, wide-ranging and fair-minded; it is the best of its kind on offer. (Barry Dainton, Times Literary Supplement )
This is simply a superb book in metaphysics - handsomely written, cleverly argued, and exceedingly clear. (Hud Hudson, Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews )
Sider does not deny that this four-dimensionalist conception of persisting things is counterintuitive. His claim is that, all things considered, it yields a more coherent ontology than any of its competitors. His defence of this claim is impressive: bold, clear, wide-ranging and fair-minded; it is the best of its kind on offer. (Barry Dainton, Times Literary Supplement )
The Philosophical Quarterly
"Sider's efforts have opened the gate to a fertile field in logical space."
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.
Inside This Book
(Learn More)
Suggested Tags from Similar Products(What's this?)Be the first one to add a relevant tag (keyword that's strongly related to this product)
|
Customer Reviews
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
Format:Hardcover
14/5/10
Mr Theodore Sider is considered one of the stronger ontologists.
Oxford, nor others publish many texts about ontology, nor metaphysics, as such works require extremely sharp acuity of mind for a reader to comprehend with meaning. To write a book, the author must have very clear objectives and to accomplish the goals within the text. My opinion is that the last argument is much moreso the case with ontology.
Although I was happy not to consider myself an ontologist, I am nonetheless inclined to comment upon the drift of this book, which presents as a very sound and sensibly indirect assault upon the Many Worlds Interpretation, and concepts such as the multiverse and n-dimensions.
KM
AMAZON HAVE ALLOWED SOMEONE TO ALTER THE WORDING AND PHRASING OF MY REVIEW.
YOU WON'T BE SEEING MANY MORE REVIEWS FROM ME. SO COMPARE WITH THE RENDERINGS OF OTHERS BEFORE FEELING PLEASED ABOUT THAT. POLICEMEN DECIDE ON YOUR BEHALF, REMEMBER ME THIS WAY.
Mr Theodore Sider is considered one of the stronger ontologists.
Oxford, nor others publish many texts about ontology, nor metaphysics, as such works require extremely sharp acuity of mind for a reader to comprehend with meaning. To write a book, the author must have very clear objectives and to accomplish the goals within the text. My opinion is that the last argument is much moreso the case with ontology.
Although I was happy not to consider myself an ontologist, I am nonetheless inclined to comment upon the drift of this book, which presents as a very sound and sensibly indirect assault upon the Many Worlds Interpretation, and concepts such as the multiverse and n-dimensions.
KM
AMAZON HAVE ALLOWED SOMEONE TO ALTER THE WORDING AND PHRASING OF MY REVIEW.
YOU WON'T BE SEEING MANY MORE REVIEWS FROM ME. SO COMPARE WITH THE RENDERINGS OF OTHERS BEFORE FEELING PLEASED ABOUT THAT. POLICEMEN DECIDE ON YOUR BEHALF, REMEMBER ME THIS WAY.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
Amazon.com:
3 reviews
42 of 44 people found the following review helpful
Best metaphysics book of the year!
16 July 2003
Format:Paperback
Hud Hudson, in a review of Ted Sider's book, says, "This is simply a superb book in metaphysics - handsomely written, cleverly argued, and exceedingly clear." Of course, Hudson happens to agree with almost every thesis Sider defends in the book. But I don't. In fact, I happen to disagree with almost every position defended in Sider's book. So what do I think of the book? I think it is simply a superb book in metaphysics - handsomely written, cleverly argued, and exceedingly clear. And I think it is notable that both friends and foes of the views defended in the book will find it to be extremely valuable. That is a real mark of distinction in philosophy, and my hat is off to Sider for producing such an outstanding work.
What is the book about? Mainly the question of whether physical objects have temporal parts. A temporal part of x is, roughly, an object that exists for a shorter time than x but that exactly overlaps x throughout its existence. Sider believes, for example, that you have a temporal part that exists (only) from noon to 1pm today, and that perfectly overlaps you throughout that time. His view allows him to give neat and clean solutions to all manner of metaphysical problems (including the problem of how a time traveler who meets his former self could be both sitting and standing at the same time), and to do various other wonderful things.
Although this is primarily a work for academic philosophers, it is clear enough that non-philosophers will be able to follow it, and to benefit from a careful reading of it. I highly recommend Four-Dimensionalism to professional philosophers, philosophy students (both graduate and undergraduate), and anyone else who is interested in questions about time and space.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
A (Suprisingly) Enjoyable Defense of Four-Dimensionalism
10 Aug 2010
Format:Paperback
'Four-Dimensionalism' is a great book. Sider defends Four-Dimensionalism with great clarity and force. Four-Dimensionalism holds (roughly) that, just as you have spatial parts--e.g. hands, cells, simples, etc.--you have "temporal" parts. A temporal part is a part of you that exists at a certain time in your existence. A consequence of this view is that, at a particular moment, you don't "wholly" exist, because your existence is spread out in time. (Four-Dimensionalism contrasts with Three-Dimensionalism, which holds that you "wholly exist" at every moment you exist.) What's nice about this book is that it takes a difficult, possibly obscure, view and makes it a joy to read about.
The book begins with an "Introduction." Unlike most Introductions, Sider's is important to read because it begins by setting forth the philosophical method and picture Sider is utilizing. (In fact, at several points in the book, Sider falls back on the points he makes in the Introduction.) The book is divided into six chapters. The first presents the "Four-Dimensionalism" picture, and motivates it by showing its ability to handle certain conceptual problems. The second could stand alone, and is a defense of the "B-theory" of time, which Sider assumes for the remainder of the book. The third attempts to state exactly what the Three/Four-Dimensionalism fuss is about. The final three chapters, which take up the bulk of the book, constitute a defense of Four-Dimensionalism--the first two provide arguments for the view, the last defends it against objections. (The book also contains a sizable list of references.)
Sider's writing is clear and easy to follow. At points, things get difficult, and some knowledge of physics is helpful for several sections; but on a whole, a limited amount of specialized knowledge is sufficient to appreciate this book. One thing I liked about it was Sider's approach. He argues that--when all the votes are in--Four-Dimensionalism is the best view, which allows him to be frank about the various strengths of arguments for and against his view. Many of his arguments are persuasive, and he's fairly systematic, considering many different objections. In the end, I learned much from it and would recommend it to anyone interested in metaphysics, ontology, or philosophy of time.
The book begins with an "Introduction." Unlike most Introductions, Sider's is important to read because it begins by setting forth the philosophical method and picture Sider is utilizing. (In fact, at several points in the book, Sider falls back on the points he makes in the Introduction.) The book is divided into six chapters. The first presents the "Four-Dimensionalism" picture, and motivates it by showing its ability to handle certain conceptual problems. The second could stand alone, and is a defense of the "B-theory" of time, which Sider assumes for the remainder of the book. The third attempts to state exactly what the Three/Four-Dimensionalism fuss is about. The final three chapters, which take up the bulk of the book, constitute a defense of Four-Dimensionalism--the first two provide arguments for the view, the last defends it against objections. (The book also contains a sizable list of references.)
Sider's writing is clear and easy to follow. At points, things get difficult, and some knowledge of physics is helpful for several sections; but on a whole, a limited amount of specialized knowledge is sufficient to appreciate this book. One thing I liked about it was Sider's approach. He argues that--when all the votes are in--Four-Dimensionalism is the best view, which allows him to be frank about the various strengths of arguments for and against his view. Many of his arguments are persuasive, and he's fairly systematic, considering many different objections. In the end, I learned much from it and would recommend it to anyone interested in metaphysics, ontology, or philosophy of time.
11 of 16 people found the following review helpful
A fabulous book! A pleasure to read!
3 Nov 2002
Format:Hardcover
This book should be required reading for anyone interested in analytic metaphysics. Not only is the book interesting in its own right, it also provides a model for what rigorous argumentation and clear presentation can be. I recommend it most highly!
Were these reviews helpful?
Let us know
Customer Discussions
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|
Listmania!
|
|
Look for similar items by category
Look for similar items by subject
Feedback
- Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
- I am the Author, and I want to comment on my book.
- I am the Publisher, and I want to comment on this book.
|
