|
|
8 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Terrible book. Title very misleading., 11 Jun 1998
By A Customer
We purchased this book with the expectation that it would suggest a diet that could reduce chronic pain for my mother, who suffers from permanent nerve damage from an injury. After all, the title does say "Foods That Fight Pain".We were extremely disappointed in the book as it contains nothing that would help my mother at all. A more appropriate title would be "A Very Extreme Vegan Diet That Could Help You Avoid Having Certain Painful Conditions That Are Triggered In Some People By Certain Foods". Dr. Barnard's diet may certainly *prevent* certain kinds of pain, but there's nothing in it about *fighting* existing pain. If you have migraines, fibromyalgia, or any of the narrow range of other chronic pain conditions that may be brought on partly or entirely by diet, this book may be of help to you. However, if you have chronic pain due to injury (as my mother does) or disease, this book is useless. I can basically sum up Dr. Barnard's diet right here: cut out all meats, fish, poultry, wheat, corn, milk, citrus fruit, tomatoes, soy products (tofu), nuts, and eggs. He suggests that you eat only certain fruits, vegetables, rice, and beans. His rationale for cutting out all of the forbidden foods above is that none of them were available to our ancient ancestors, and therefore they aren't suited to our digestive systems because they weren't available while our digestive systems were evolving. He doesn't even follow his own logic during his extremely silly explanation of his diet philosophy. For instance, he says on one page that we shouldn't eat meat etc. because apes and other primates don't and they are our closest genetic relatives. He then makes a strong point of the fact that apes don't cook. Then, he goes on to suggest that we refuse to eat these various foods on the grounds that apes don't eat them, but cooking's OK. Huh? Apes don't eat meat=meat bad. Apes don't cook=cooking good. It makes no sense at all. This was by far the nuttiest diet philosoph! y I've ever had the misfortune to read. We feel that this book was a colossal waste of money, at least for us. If you have migraines, fibromyalgia, etc., just ask your doctor if a vegan diet that also eliminates wheat and corn might help you.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|