Most Helpful Customer Reviews
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Well Worth A Voyage, 31 July 2009
FLOATING ISLAND by JULES VERNE
Although one of Jules Verne's lesser known novels, as part of his 'Extraordinary Voyages' collection, there is still much to enjoy about 'The Floating Island'*. Written in 1895 towards the end of his career, the book cannot match the excitement of the more celebrated trio of 'Around The World in 80 Days', 'Journey To The Centre Of The Earth' or '20,000 Leagues Under The Sea', despite there being many similarities with the last of his great works listed here.
The premise of the novel is excellent. A man-made island inhabited and funded exclusively by America's richest citizens tours the Pacific ocean and its archipelagos, taking the idea of the late 19th century and early 20th century cruise ships to the ultimate extreme. With typical flair, in the book's earlier chapters, Verne describes the mechanics and structure (including the impressive Milliard City) of the island so convincingly, that this absurd idea seems plausible to the reader. Always ahead of his time, there is something 'Truman Show'-esque about this artificial paradise, and the 'perfect' society that its accommodates. Similarly entertaining is the principal characters' (a Parisian string quartet) arrival on Floating Island, which takes the form of a kidnap / business deal by the impresario, Calistus Munbar. The passages detailing musicians' reactions to the spectacle of Floating Island and their 'imprisonment' upon it are full of creativity and amusement, and reveal the lighter side of Verne's writing.
However, where the novel disappoints is its tendency to morph into a Pacific Islands travelogue once the premise of the story is in place. Many if the chapters are dominated by descriptions of the flora, fauna, inhabitants and lifestyles of the regions where Floating Island docks. To a reader in the late 1800s, no doubt these would have held a fascinating appeal. However, in the modern age, when access to a wealth of written, photographic and film material is instantly available, such painstaking description does at times impede upon the flow of the story and the action.
Nevertheless, overlooking the occasionally awkward blending of fact and fiction, 'Floating Island' deserves to be revisited. Indeed, the story itself (which would be best abridged to novella length in the 21st century) is as creative and thought-provoking as those of the author's more celebrated works. If you haven't read any of Jules Verne's books, begin elsewhere with the three famous titles. If you enjoy them, then certainly do not dismiss the possibility of a voyage on 'Floating Island'.
* Confusingly, 'Floating Island' is also known as both 'Propeller Island' and 'The Pearl Of The Pacific'.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
Awesome spectacle but not thrilling., 16 May 2011
This is from 1895 and is an adventure novel with sci-fi elements.This is set in an unmentioned year probably in the early 20th century and follows a French string quartet as they become unwilling guests on Milliard Island,a four and a half mile by three,floating luxury man-made island.This creation is propelled by electric screws,with power generated by solid petroleum blocks(cleaner than coal).It is populated by super-rich Americans and it cruises the South Pacific Islands.We get a lit of interesting facts and figures about the 'Island',and it is quite an interesting idea(I would imagine it would work on a smaller scale).Attacks by pirates and a baffling selection of dangerous animals stand out as highlights.
The plot is quite uneven with big moments rushed,and most of the main events at the end.This book is mostly describing the cruise through the Pacific,listing the Islands,their histories and cultures,19th Century psuedoscience is well represented with Verne occasionally grading the natives in chilling style.
Maybe not the most scintillating read-but the reader is left in awe of Verne's vision and the huge spectacle he gives us.
The copy reviewed is a 1920 Sampson Low.This is Voyages Extraordinaires No.41.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Dull and uneventful story., 18 Mar 1999
By A Customer - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Floating Island (Pacific Basin Books) (Paperback)
Having read 13 other books by Jules Verne, most of which are considered classics, I went into this lesser known novel with high expectations. Simply put, FLOATING ISLAND sunk, excuse me, stunk. It goes on and on about nothing. The reader follows four French musicians as they find themselves on a large manmade floating island in the Pacific Ocean. As the story goes along they visit island chain after island chain. In typical Verne fashion there are endless details and descriptions of the islands they visit. Unfortunately, that is pretty much all the book is about, describing islands and their inhabitants. There is a plot buried in there somewhere which features the observations of the musicians, and the social structure and events of the island's inhabitants. There is a good bit of social commentary by Verne to be found late in this novel as the island's inhabitants begin to argue and the island is split politically and socially. Unfortunately, there is too little excitement and too little plot to save this sinking ship.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A GOOD BOOK, 10 July 2002
By myshiak - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Floating Island (Pacific Basin Books) (Paperback)
I disagree with statements that say that the book is dull and uneventful. It is true that it is not the best novel written by Jules Verne, but it is still interesting. It has a scientific element in it (the idea of a ship-like structure that is about the size of a small island is not too far-fetched), characters who you can identify with or find interesting, cultural and anthropological insights into various islands in the Pacific Ocean, humor and social satire. In fact, I would rank it higher than most of the books in the bookstores' Science Fiction section.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An intriguing satire, 20 Dec 2007
By Victor Rodriguez - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Floating Island (Pacific Basin Books) (Paperback)
Although Jules Verne is rightly credited with being the "father of science fiction," he was also an astute and biting social commentator. But unlike his younger contemporary H.G. Wells, whose social novels, Tono-Bungay, Ann Veronica, Kips, ...Mr. Polly, etc., are set apart from his science fiction, Verne wrote his social novels within the context of his celebrated Extraordinary Voyages. In his 1895 novel The Floating Island Verne utilized the premise that worked so well in his most popular works. In such thrillers as 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea, Robur the Conqueror, and Master of the World, to name just a few, a marvelous craft is invented by a rich and eccentric misanthrope, who tries to force world leaders to end their destructive ways-or else. His ship is inadvertently boarded by outsiders who are immediately impressed by the ingenious captain and his marvelous craft, and the trouble begins.
In The Floating Island a group of traveling French string musicians, who call themselves The Quartette Party, are on their way to San Diego to give a concert. Somehow they get lost in Southern California, but are rescued by a stranger named Calistus Munbar. They soon arrive in a place called Madeleine Bay and discover to their consternation that they've boarded an enormous vessel, believing they were still on land, on its way across the Pacific Ocean. Indignant at first, they agree to stay aboard for a year, entertain, and receive a handsome reward at tour's end.
Constructed by a group of American millionaires who'd formed a venture called The Floating Island Company, of Madeleine Bay, California, Floating Island is an iron vessel made of thousands of caissons and metal slabs, held together by millions of rivets. It is oval shaped, four-and-a-half miles long, three miles wide, with a circumference of about eleven miles. It is impervious to inclement weather or artillery barrage; but subject to piratical attacks and plunder. Little food is grown in its shallow deck soil; so most sustenance is imported. Communication with the mainland via telephone and telegraph. Powered by huge dynamos, it travels at a speed of eight knots an hour; thus taking up to a year to circumnavigate the Pacific. Floating Island is a veritable industrial wonder and supreme achievement. Here all material cares are banished and most labor eliminated. The rich simply rest, cruise and sightsee. Verne takes the envious reader to Hawaii, the Marquesas, Tahiti, Tonga and several other archipelagoes. But this "the pearl of the Pacific" and its population, most of them living in its capitol, Milliard City, are a quarrelling lot divided by their loyalty to two rival leaders. One is named Jem Tankerdon, the other Nat Coverly, and their dislike for one another is intense. One favors making Floating Island an industrial enterprise, the other a rural environment. The two factions refer to themselves as either the Starboardites or the Larboardites. This mutual and volatile enmity naturally leads to the novel's spectacular climax.
The Floating Island is obviously a Jules Verne satire of late 19th century American life; our Gilded Age. Earlier in the century the Frenchman viewed this country as a great nation with the potential to do wonderful things for humanity. But by the 1890s, in Verne's view, it had become a nation populated by greedy industrialist whose extravagant lifestyles separated them from a vast underclass-the majority of the population. The friction between the Starboardites and the Larboardites recalls our Civil War conflict. And Verne prophesied that rampant industrialization would destroy society as we know it. "When a journey begins badly it rarely ends well," Verne hints in the opening sentence of The Floating Island. As in most Verne novels the characters are a bit flat or comical, but the action is always sustained and his prophetic gifts amazing. Though somewhat lengthy, with several pointless and dragging scenes, this is nonetheless a vastly entertaining novel from the pen of a man who continues to surprise and thrill those of us who still marvel at his uncanny vision.
|
|
|