Flat Earth: The History of an Infamous Idea
and over one million other books are available for Amazon Kindle .
Learn more
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
 Trade In this Item for up to £0.25
Trade in Flat Earth: The History of an Infamous Idea for an Amazon.co.uk gift card of up to £0.25, which you can then spend on millions of items across the site. Plus, get an extra £5 when you trade in books worth £10 or more until June 30, 2012. Trade-in values may vary (terms apply). Find more products eligible for trade-in.
|
Frequently Bought Together
Product details
|
More About the Author
Product Description
Review
"An energetic, all-inclusive, and amusing account of man's impressive capacity for self-delusion. Every creationist should read it." ---Steve Jones, author of "Darwin's Ghost
""Highly entertaining and often hilarious." ---"Sunday Telegraph
""The focus of Garwood's impressive research is a forgotten episode
in the history of science." ---"New Scientist
""A glorious romp around the world of Flat Earthism." ---"Daily Express
""Garwood's often hilarious book is a serious look at an aberrant belief and those who took it up in modern times, centuries after the ?at Earth had been scientifically dismissed. . . . Garwood's books shows just how doggedly faith in an unscienti?c idea can hold." ---"The Commercial Dispatch
""[A] quirky and highly entertaining slice of intellectual history. Elicits plentiful laughter and astonishment." ---"Sunday Times
""Wonderful . . . dispassionate, and understanding." ---"Financial Times"
""Highly entertaining and often hilarious." ---"Sunday Telegraph
""The focus of Garwood's impressive research is a forgotten episode
in the history of science." ---"New Scientist
""A glorious romp around the world of Flat Earthism." ---"Daily Express
""Garwood's often hilarious book is a serious look at an aberrant belief and those who took it up in modern times, centuries after the ?at Earth had been scientifically dismissed. . . . Garwood's books shows just how doggedly faith in an unscienti?c idea can hold." ---"The Commercial Dispatch
""[A] quirky and highly entertaining slice of intellectual history. Elicits plentiful laughter and astonishment." ---"Sunday Times
""Wonderful . . . dispassionate, and understanding." ---"Financial Times"
The Guardian
'Prodigiously researched, Flat Earth is a fascinating study of the power of ideas.'
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Customer Reviews
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
Format:Paperback
Looking at the title one could be forgiven for thinking: Not very interesting, surely? After all nobody believes in it now. People in olden times used to think the world was flat, indeed the Church taught that, but Columbus proved the world was round, and with the development of modern scientific knowledge nobody can possibly hold to such an idea.
If you think that you would be wrong on all counts. This book not only shows this, it offers insights and understanding to anyone interested in the relationship between science and religion and how what we "know" can be shaped by personal factors we are unaware of.
As Garwood explains, the Ancients knew the world was round, and the Christian Church had no problem with the idea. Some figures in the early Church rejected the idea, apparently because it was part of the "pagan knowledge" they were turning their back on, but they were a minority. The idea that "the Church taught the Earth was flat" was promoted later by anti-religious writers pursuing their own agenda.
Similarly, those who opposed Columbus's proposed trip knew perfectly well the Earth was round; they were against it for sound reasons. In fact their ideas were closer to the truth than Columbus's, but he was very lucky. Again, the facts were misrepresented to suit later writers' agenda (putting down the Catholic Church and building up Columbus as a prototype for American "rugged individualism").
Flat-Earthism as a vocal pseudo-scientific movement actually arose in Nineteenth-Century England, whence it spread to the USA. It was established by fundamentalist Christians who were reacting to the advance of scientific knowledge, which they saw as a godless force or conspiracy aimed at destroying the Christian faith. In response they constructed a "Christian" model of the Universe based on scattered verses from the Bible.
Although its heyday was more than a century ago, Flat-Earthism still persists in that milieu inhabited by anti-scientists, conspiracy theorists, and fundamentalist "young Earth" Creationists. Such people tend to see themselves as blessed with a special insight and battling heroically against Godless or conspiratorial forces. Their reaction to the threatening modern unsettled and unsettling world is to build themselves a mental fort and inhabit it secure in their own beliefs and their willingness to face the enemies all around. They have retreated to "the old certainties" as a reaction to change in the world around them.Perhaps it is understandable if they see science and religion as fundamentally opposing forces rather than paths to understanding that deal with different aspects of human life.
This is a fascinating well-researched book. The author is never patronising or contemptuous of the Flat-Earthers, who are shown as real, sincere, people, while the issues are presented fairly and thoroughly (eprhaps a little too thoroughly in places, some skipping will aid the reading of certain passeages). I enjoyed it and recommend it.
If you think that you would be wrong on all counts. This book not only shows this, it offers insights and understanding to anyone interested in the relationship between science and religion and how what we "know" can be shaped by personal factors we are unaware of.
As Garwood explains, the Ancients knew the world was round, and the Christian Church had no problem with the idea. Some figures in the early Church rejected the idea, apparently because it was part of the "pagan knowledge" they were turning their back on, but they were a minority. The idea that "the Church taught the Earth was flat" was promoted later by anti-religious writers pursuing their own agenda.
Similarly, those who opposed Columbus's proposed trip knew perfectly well the Earth was round; they were against it for sound reasons. In fact their ideas were closer to the truth than Columbus's, but he was very lucky. Again, the facts were misrepresented to suit later writers' agenda (putting down the Catholic Church and building up Columbus as a prototype for American "rugged individualism").
Flat-Earthism as a vocal pseudo-scientific movement actually arose in Nineteenth-Century England, whence it spread to the USA. It was established by fundamentalist Christians who were reacting to the advance of scientific knowledge, which they saw as a godless force or conspiracy aimed at destroying the Christian faith. In response they constructed a "Christian" model of the Universe based on scattered verses from the Bible.
Although its heyday was more than a century ago, Flat-Earthism still persists in that milieu inhabited by anti-scientists, conspiracy theorists, and fundamentalist "young Earth" Creationists. Such people tend to see themselves as blessed with a special insight and battling heroically against Godless or conspiratorial forces. Their reaction to the threatening modern unsettled and unsettling world is to build themselves a mental fort and inhabit it secure in their own beliefs and their willingness to face the enemies all around. They have retreated to "the old certainties" as a reaction to change in the world around them.Perhaps it is understandable if they see science and religion as fundamentally opposing forces rather than paths to understanding that deal with different aspects of human life.
This is a fascinating well-researched book. The author is never patronising or contemptuous of the Flat-Earthers, who are shown as real, sincere, people, while the issues are presented fairly and thoroughly (eprhaps a little too thoroughly in places, some skipping will aid the reading of certain passeages). I enjoyed it and recommend it.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
Format:Paperback
Perhaps the most interesting aspect of this book for me was that as soon as I started to read the accounts of the nineteenth century flat-earthers I was immediately struck by the similarity between them and the modern day climate change deniers or those who believe that they can prove the moon landings were faked. So the story does have a lot of resonance today.
Overall I would say this book is well written, interesting and entertaining in parts but its main failing is that it is too long. It could easily be edited down to half its length without losing anything of importance.
Overall I would say this book is well written, interesting and entertaining in parts but its main failing is that it is too long. It could easily be edited down to half its length without losing anything of importance.
Format:Kindle Edition
Clearly a great deal of research has gone into this book, and Garwood deserves applause for it. The tale of stupidity and blind argument is told as any great story should be. My only issue with the book is the sheer amount of detail, which caused me to become distracted in places. Otherwise great!
Would you like to see more reviews about this item?
Were these reviews helpful?
Let us know
Most Recent Customer Reviews
A fascinating glimpse into science and public debate
This fascinating, if slightly overlong, book is well worth reading for understanding how public scientific debate is constructed. Read more
Published 24 months ago by Paul T. Gannon
A rather flat book
With books like fermat's last theorem or zero a biography what the authors do is take the central concept and use it to guide you through the story of mathematics or physics. Read more
Published on 4 Mar 2009 by J. Duducu
Fascinating conflict
The book gives a fascinating account into the debates that once raged over what is now generally accepted as fact, but in Victorian times was regarded by some as a crackpot... Read more
Published on 10 Feb 2009 by Old Al
A triumph that flattens Intelligent Design
In historical study, there is a dangerous tendency to mask ignorance as pedantry and claim one understands a subject without context, knowledge of the relevant literature and only... Read more
Published on 7 Sep 2007 by C. A. Justin
Review of Garwood (2007) - Flat Earth: The History of an Infamous Idea
The pathways through which the history of scientific progress can be mapped are strewn with the remains of overturned ideas and outdated pronouncements, some cranky and (with... Read more
Published on 5 Sep 2007 by J. Ollerton
The Flat Earth in a flat book
This book, whilst informative on modern Zetetics, as the flat-earthers dub themselves, is sadly let down by a veiled attack on the Enlightenment and a complete misrepresentation of... Read more
Published on 29 Aug 2007 by Musadin
Faith Rampant Over Science
You remember the story about the frightened sailors who went with Columbus in 1492, but were sure that they were going to sail off the edge of the world. Read more
Published on 22 May 2007 by R. Hardy
Listmania!
Look for similar items by category
- Books > History > Ancient History & Civilisation
- Books > History > Other Historical Subjects > History of Science
- Books > Science & Nature > Astronomy & Cosmology > Astronomy
- Books > Science & Nature > Astronomy & Cosmology > Cosmology
- Books > Science & Nature > Astronomy & Cosmology > Reference
- Books > Science & Nature > History & Philosophy > Reference
- Books > Scientific, Technical & Medical > Astronomy & Cosmology > Cosmology
Look for similar items by subject
Feedback
- Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
- I am the Author, and I want to comment on my book.
- I am the Publisher, and I want to comment on this book.
|
