The first book I read by Jude Deveraux was SUMMERHOUSE. I really enjoyed that story, about four friends with a little bit of "magic" mixed in. I then read Mulberry Tree, which I really liked. I was really hoping I would like FIRST IMPRESSIONS, and while I liked the idea (my "First Impression" was that it would be a good read!), I found that it dragged on a little too much, and as the chapters moved forward, I found myself thinking, "What else could go wrong?" Everytime it seemed like the "mystery" was solved so that the story could shift from mystery to relationships, the characters were hit with another mystery to solve, and more danger ahead. By the time I was about 3/4 through the book, I had had enough mystery and danger. I wanted to know what happened with the relationships that were formed in the beginning of the story.
Even once I finished the book, I wasn't completely satsified. Too many questions remained unanswered, and it was all wrapped up nice and neat and "tied with a bow." After reading the last few pages, I didn't think it left a "Lasting Impression" on me!!
The characters introduced in the beginning of the book provided promise for a character driven story, but seemed to loose momentum along the way. For example, I found the daughter, Melissa a little annoying and bratty by the time she reappeared later on in the book. Her first appearances in the beginning of the story didn't make the same impression she made later on. The character of Brad was confident and strong-willed when first introduced, but later turned into a bit of a whimp!! I found this type of inconsistency several times throughout the book. Characters seemed to do a 180 degree turn-around, and took on different personalities as the story progressed. While this may seem to be a form of character development or growth under the pen of other authors, I didn't find this to be the case in this book. The story is definitely more plot-ridden, rather than character-driven, so I didn't find myself emotionally attached to any of the characters.
I'm also not a big fan of mystery, which this book is loaded with. A little bit of mystery mixed in with romance is fine, but FIRST IMPRESSIONS took it a little too far. I found myself skimming the paragraphs, grabbing the highlights, just to get through it. At times I felt like I was reading the latest script was a romantic-comedy (kinda like the Meg Ryan & Kevin Kline characters from French Kiss!). I could see this story on the big sceen, but it just didn't play out well within the pages of a novel.
For fans of Jude Deveraux, it's a good one to check out of the library and true fans may not want to miss it, but new readers who have never read Jude Deveraux may want to skip this one, and read one of her older releases. Maybe then, come back and read FIRST IMPRESSIONS, and see what type of "impressions" Ms. Deveraux makes on you!