This is an excellent video adaptation of an excellent book by the same name. When reviewing the book I withheld the fifth star because I had been slightly disappointed at not finding more on the topic (dear to my own heart) of branch lines. There is even less about branch lines in the video, but a video has to make some excisions of secondary material or it will lose its focus, I recognise that, and in any case I don't want to be Scrooge in my marking at Christmas. 1st-Take are a Bristol-based company, their emphasis is largely on West Country topics, so I shall follow the example of a famous BBC radio panellist many years ago who used to say in a rich Somerset accent 'Oi'll give it foive.'
If this notice finds any readers, perhaps I may refer them to my review of the book on this site rather than reprocess much of what that has to say here. The quality of the camera-work is admirable, some of the most overexposed beauty-spots such as Ribblehead are captured with real freshness and imagination, and Wolmar is a model of the enthusiastic but self-disciplined professional in his commentary.
The choice of stills is a matter in which the video is obviously going to score over the book, and as a bonus there is a short extra section consisting of stills entirely. The parade of pictures is one that I found completely engrossing, and if I have any fault to find it is that Wolmar ends rather abruptly. I felt this slightly in the book as well, and coming reluctantly to the end of Wolmar's account I called across to the screen 'Oh go on, stick your neck out and risk a few predictions.'
I shall have to make my own predictions or look elsewhere for them, but in the meantime this is in most ways a really first-class and professionally executed film, and if you can find a copy I recommend it.