Mr Sondheim is a tough critic of himself. The lyrics to Maria he finds wet: 'a wetness, I regret to say, which persists throughout all the romantic lyrics in the show'. Some of the lyrics to America, he suggests, 'melt in the mouth as gracelessly as peanut butter and are impossible to comprehend.' His biggest regret, though, was, initially, not being able to write the 'harsher and more realistic expletive he felt should finish the song Officer Krupke. However, he eventually came to realise that Bernstein's suggestion of 'Krup you!' was an improvement, in fact, 'the best line in the show!'(A sentiment presumably shared by Larry David, who used it for a great Curb Your Enthusiasm episode.)
You can see from these few excerpts from the chapter on West Side Story alone, what good companionship Sondheim's commentary provides for readers in this volume of lyrics. This is a wonderful book already and I have only begun to dip in here and there to the musicals I know better.
What range Sondheim shows from 'I Feel Pretty'(a song, unfortunately, that will never be quite the same again for me after Adam Sandler and Jack Nicholson's version in Anger Management) to 'Pretty Women'! The light, deliberate simplicity of the lyrics of West Side Story and the teasing, tortuous duet of sex and death in Sweeney Todd. Nothing much darker in musical theatre than the songs and lyrics of the latter:
'City on Fire! / Rats in the grass / And the lunatics yelling in the streets! / It's the end of the world! Yes!' (City on Fire).
This book is an essential purchase for Sondheim fans. Whether Mr Sondheim is a genius, or can be compared to Shakespeare and Chekov, as Trevor Nunn writes on the back of this book, is debatable, but he is undoubtedly a composer and lyricist of the very finest order, and, in this book, a great friend to the reader. After all, as Sondheim knows well, we are all seeking company. He provides it.