Tom Meeker, tall, blonde and handsome, in his late twenties, is in his second year of the priesthood serving in small town Cottonwood, Montana. Unaware of his sexuality, he is at first puzzled over his feelings for the good looking young half-breed drop out Vidal Stump (the Fancy Dancer) who comes to him for confession. The two strike up a friendship as Tom sees there is much more to Vidal than the drunken brawler, despite the disapproval of Tom's superior Father Vance. But when the inevitable occurs Tom is thrown into turmoil about his calling and his sexuality, and fearful that he will be found out as gay in the small community of Cottonwood.
However with Vidal's help Tom finds help in the form of a group of disaffected Catholics in Denver who are working to aid other Catholic gays. But will Tom be able to remain in the priesthood, and what of the long term prospects for him and Vidal?
The Fancy Dancer is an interesting story, but I had to keep reminding myself that this was written in 1976 to avoid it seeming rather naive at times. Both Tom and Vidal are interesting, appealing yet very different characters, the other characters are well drawn and there is a good sense of place. The dilemma's facing Tom are well thought through, and the story has a satisfying conclusion.