If you are already initiated into the world of Hootie then the first thing that strikes you is that this album is less pop orientated than CRV and for those who haven't got other Hootie albums then this will come as a breath of fresh air.
I can't help but have the feeling that this album was very much influenced by the stylings of Counting Crows and a desire to expand and not just rest on their laurels and a number of the songs work really well but overall it lacks some of the poignancy that Adam Duritz lends to his songs.
The standout for me is the sublime 'So Strange' which reunites Darius and Nanci Griffiths, after some great work for MTV and 'The Dust Bowl Symphony', in a song that is just a great feat in vocal harmonising and the simple pop lyrics that landed Hootie in the spotlight.
One of the main criticisms I've heard about this album is that it is a little bit monotone and lacking in pep and although 'Old Man And Me' is one of the most up tempo songs they have ever done you can't help but feel that another couple like it would have helped push 'Fairweather Johnson' over the hill, not to say that whats here isn't good but it is a tad monotone and lacking a little pep.
This is a good album but not a great one. Fans of mopers like Travis and Coldplay would probably lap this up, although come to think of it Darius Rucker can actually sing so I don't know.
There are some top tunes here and its well worth listening to especially if your a fan of 'August and Everything After' (and if you're not then see a priest and beat yourself with reeds) and not a particularly great fan of 'Cracked Rear View'. Darius can sing, Mark is a good axe man and the rhytm section are good too. Good harmless pop-rock fun with a slight edge. Well worth considering.