Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A pleasing read, 24 Mar 2008
Aya Fuse had been brought up in the aftermath of the "Mind Rain" initiated by Tally Youngblood, so is one of the first to experience this completely new style of life. New surgery is being constantly invented, ranging from new livers and infra red vision to "Radical Honesty", the brain surgery that makes it impossible to lie. True, minds aren't being controlled anymore, but there are disadvantages to this. In "Pretty Time", everyone could have nearly everything they wanted just by asking their high tech homes, but in this new era, only the very famous can have anything like this luxury. The city revolves around the face ranks, numbers representing the inhabitants' degrees of fame. At the top are people like the legendary Tally Youngblood, the clique founders and the best reporters. At the bottom are the hundreds of thousands of "Extras", whose names have never been known and probably never will. Aya is determined to fight her way out of life as an extra, and following the strange ways of the unique new cliques constantly forming is the easiest method of doing so. Aya thinks she has found the key to fame when she discovers some of the least famous people in the city, with face ranks in the bottom thousand, performing incredible stunts. To exploit them, she joins their group, resulting in the discovery of a hidden weapon in the mountains that could destroy life on Earth. Suddenly Aya becomes famous, but fame doesn't seem so good when you're the one risking your life to get to the bottom of this.
Although certainly not as good as the others in this series, "Extras" is still an engrossing read that will keep you captivated. The plot twists come regularly, always completely unpredictable, and the suspense is constantly building up.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Fame Making Return, 7 Jul 2008
I was a little reticent about picking up 'Extras', having found 'Specials' the third instalment of the 'Uglies Trilogy' the weakest of the the three. This combined with the fact the trilogy was now suddenly billed as a quartet, did not bode well. It may have worked for Douglas Adams but as a general rule, revisiting a completed series, produces novels that are shadows of the original stories. Not so in this case.
There is a a very strong argument for Extras being the best of the four. It has the same easy to read style and I found the story more coherent than in the previous novels. It seemed to me, now that Westerfeld has had a few years to kick about in his future world, he feels a lot more at home there.
In Extras, it's our obsession with fame that comes under the microscope; the central characters live in a city where your fame ranking determines everything about you. It's a fantastic metaphor for twenty first century culture. Journalism also comes under the microscope and Westerfeld explores the power of honesty and'Truth-Slanting', the idea that there are multiple ways to spin a story.
Like the previous novels in the series, Extras is a terrific read. Westerfeld writes exciting stories, using shades of grey that should provoke the reader into thinking a little more about the world we live in. I think he is a sadly underrated author, if Westerfeld lived inside his own creation, he'd barely exist and that would be a crying shame.
|
|
|
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Unimpressed, 11 Oct 2008
After really enjoying the Uglies trilogy I bought this book as soon as amazon recomended it to me. However it really disapointed me as it was very predictable and although a few twists where envolved it did not seem like the captivating world of Uglies i left behind. Although it is ment to be baised after the 'mind rain' I could not get 'into it' as I did with the others. It was a good idea for a the future though but I think it would probally stand better on it's own with slightly different characters.
|
|
|
|