Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
16 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Superb follow-up from the makers of The Office, 29 Oct 2008
Ricky Gervais and Stephen Merchant's follow-up to The Office was burdened with the weight of how to succeed one of the most popular sitcoms in recent years. Arguably, they have made an even better series.
The Extras follows the fortunes of two struggling bit-part actors and their life on the fringes of stardom: talking to Patrick Stewart as he describes his secret project, in which all the female participants' clothes fall off ("So it's a comedy?" "No."), or Sir Ian Mckellen revealing the secret of his success - that all his lines are written in advance..
Life on the periphery of celebrity makes the majority of the narrative in the first series. Season Two gives us a chance to sample some hard won success, when Gervais' character is finally given a chance to make his cherished sitcom - a sitcom that is meant to be funny but also honest and authentic. The finished product is a pathetic affair in the vein of Some Mothers Do Have Them or My Family ("Ooh, Betty, I think the cat might have just shat out the worst sitcom of all time!" writes one critic). The final closing Specials look at whether Gervais is prepared to walk away from his possibly only chance at stardom, in order to redeem his self-respect and credibility.
People like Robert De Niro and Samuel L. Jackson have walk-on parts in Extras and those who would normally be in the background of a film take centre stage. This is no celebrity love-in, quite the opposite. Extras exposes the hollow existence of fame, especially that pursued by those who have no ostensible talent, something The Office briefly touched on.
Bottom line, though, is that Extras is hilarious. Co-writer and director Stephen Merchant, who had only a cameo in The Office, takes a major supporting role as Gervais' incompetent manager ("Barry from Eastenders" is also on his books: "I've got plenty of work lined up for you!" "Like what?" "A lightbulb upstairs needs changing"); he steels almost every scene he's in. Extras is another fantastic achievement from Gervais and Merchant. The only debate is whether it's better than The Office.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Amazing in more than one way., 26 Feb 2009
I watched the entire boxset over the course of 3 nights after recieving it for Christmas, which just says it all.
But here's the thing, watch it on your own and it's not really that laugh out loud funny. It's funny in the way that the ideas BEHIND everything are funny, but it's not laugh out loud funny. And it makes up for that by being a FANTASTIC drama that you can't help but get sucked into.
There's genuine character development going on over the course of the boxset with a whole host of likable and unlikable characters (who all, by the way, turn in excellent performances.)
It saddens me to see people rating the Special lower because it's a much darker affair, because as pretentious as this will sound, the special is as much a redemption story as it is a comedy, and Andy's character truly has to hit rock bottom before he can really redeem himself and regain his self respect, and the execution is perfect.
The scene in the big brother house where Andy gives a 5 minute rant genuinely moved me to tears and is one of the most poignant statements made in recent years in the field of Comedy.
On the other hand, watch it with a friend or two and it becomes side splittingly funny.
Utterly fantastic.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Gervais hits the bulls-eye with this black comedy, 4 Feb 2009
This black comedy focuses on Andy and his best friend Maggie, who are working as extras in films but want to be "real actors with lines" in series 1. Maggie's lack of brains and social competence makes itself painfully felt, while Andy tries anything to get better roles or produce a sitcom. Andy's attempts to have someone read his sitcom script finally pay off in series 2 when he gets his own BBC sitcom loosely based on his idea. However, it turns out that he wanted to create a sort of "Office" but ended up with a lowest-common-denominator sitcom. In the film-length special he finally has fame and fortune, and is now desperate for respect and doesn't care what he does or who he hurts to get it. The special culminates in a poignant, emotional scene rarely found in sitcoms. "Extras" will have you laughing out loud, writhing in embarrassment and wiping away tears.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|