This book is strong on rhetoric but it is hard to find the substance. This may be because of the declared attitude of the author: "the knowledge of good and evil seems to be the aim of all ethical reflection. The first task of Christian ethics is to invalidate this knowledge". There is one insight that made the book worthwhile for me; in order to know what is good you need: "Intelligence, discernment, attentive observation of the given facts, all these come in lively operation. Direct inspiration must in no case be heeded or expected, for this could all to easily lead to man's abandoning himself to self- deception. In view of what is at stake there must be lofty spirit of sober self-control. Possibilities and consequences must be carefully assessed. In other words, the whole apparatus of human powers must be set in motion when it is a matter of proving what is the will of God". There is no shortcut to knowing what is good, even for a devout Christian! Business ethics as a stream of ideas
Was this review helpful to you?
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
BONHOEFFER'S UNFINISHED FINAL WORK14 May 2012
Steven H Propp
- Published on Amazon.com
Format: Unknown Binding
Dietrich Bonhoeffer (1906-1945) was a German Lutheran pastor and theologian, as well as a participant in the German Resistance movement against Nazism. He was hung for his part in a plot to assassinate Adolf Hitler. This book contains the chapters of the systematic book of ethics that Bonhoeffer was PLANNING to write, and was able to conceal from the Gestapo when he was arrested in 1943.
It begins by stating that "the knowledge of good and evil shows that (we are) no longer at one with this origin." (Pg. 17) Conscience is even "farther from the origin than shame, it presupposes disunion with God and with man." (Pg. 24) By contrast, the Christian's freedom in Jesus "is not the arbitrary choice of one amongst innumerable possibilities; it consists on the contrary precisely in the complete simplicity of His actions, which is never confronted by a plurality of possibilities." (Pg. 30) Ultimately, he concludes, "Faith alone is certainty. Everything but faith is subject to doubt." (Pg. 121)
He suggests that "The point of departure for Christian ethics is the body of Christ, the form of Christ in the form of the Church, and the formation of the Church in conformity with the form of Christ." (Pg. 84) In a section on confession (Pg. 113-115), he acknowledges that the Church "has not striven forcefully enough against the misuse of this name for an evil purpose," "has not raised her voice on behalf of the victims," "has witnessed in silence the spoilation and exploitation of the poor," etc. Later, he states that "The problem of Christian ethics is the realization among God's creatures of the revelational reality of God in Christ." (Pg. 190)
He observes that "even when it is set free in Jesus Christ conscience still confronts responsible action with the law..." (Pg. 247) For Bonhoeffer, "the ethical is not essentially a formal rational principle but a concrete relation between the giver and receiver of commands." (Pg. 273) He adds, "God's command is the only warrant for ethical discourse." (Pg. 277) He asserts, "Either God does not speak at all or else He speaks to us as definitely as He spoke to Abraham and Jacob and Moses and as definitely in Jesus Christ as He spoke to the disciples..." (pg. 278), but concedes that "God makes his commandment heard in a definite historical form." (Pg. 278)
It is tragic that Bonhoeffer was not able to finish this work, which surely would have been his magnum opus. But what we DO have is nevertheless essential reading for any student of modern theology.