My son is a fluent Spanish-speaker who is determined that his children will also speak Spanish. Thus, when he reads to my 3-year old grandson, it is always in Spanish. My grandson is into Christmas stories right now, no matter that it is the middle of summer. I bought this and took it to him on a recent visit. He loves the book whether his father is reading it in Spanish or his grandmother is telling him the story in English while we look at the wonderful pictures. Rudolph wasn't in the original story as I recall it, but my grandson cares not the least about that. Loves the book and story, no matter which language.