Most Helpful Customer Reviews
70 of 75 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An Enigmatic film experience., 10 Aug 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: Enigma [DVD] [2001] (DVD)
Enigma is a fantastic film from acclaimed director Michael Apted. Featuring Dougray Scott, Kate Winslet and Jeremy Northam, it is based on Robert Harris' book of the same name. The story is set in England during World War II and focuses on the efforts of British cryptanalysts who worked tirelessly throughout the war to break German codes and ciphers. The Germans believed that the messages encrypted on their Enigma machines were indecipherable. Tom Jericho (Scott) is one of the cryptanalysts working at Bletchley Park, the code-breaking centre of England. He is recovering from a nervous breakdown following a relationship break-up and due to the stress of his job. Having broken the Enigma codes before he returns to Bletchley to help break a new and more sophisticated German U-Boat code, only to discover that his ex-lover Claire (Saffron Burrows) has disappeared. Enlisting the help of her room-mate Hester (Winslet), Jericho sets out to find her. Meanwhile, Bletchley Park is under the surveillance of Agent Wigram (Northam), searching for a double-agent at Bletchley, determined to incriminate the missing Claire and the love-sick Jericho. Throw in a dramatic stand-off between German U-Boats, American cargo ships and the harried Bletchley cryptanalysts, as well as a car chase and a love triangle, and Engima provides an exciting 119 minutes of viewing pleasure! Kate Winslet gives a strong and assured performance, allowing Hester to add some 'Girl Power' to the largely 'Boys-Own' adventure. Dougray Scott looks suitably gaunt and worn-out as Jericho, Saffron Burrows is perfectly cast as the beautiful and enigmatic Claire and Jeremy Northam is wonderfully suave, sophisticated and cold as the ruthless government agent. The DVD contains special features such as interviews with the cast and a 'Making-of' featurette. Shots of raw, behind-the-scenes footage give you a chance to see how several of the shots in the movie were filmed, as well as an extended observation of Mick Jagger (co-Producer) as a night club extra! The behind-the-scenes footage is fantastic. I especially enjoyed hearing the actors discuss their characters and the history of Bletchley Park and its inhabitants. One problem with the Special Features on this disc is that the raw footage seems out of context. It just shows one scene being shot, then another, then another ad-infinitum. It would've been nice to have had Apted or the cinematographer give us some kind of commentary to give an insight into the filming process. Likewise, the film itself has no commentary track. Having heard Northam's insights into his performance on The Winslow Boy DVD commentary, this is a pity. Watching Enigma, I felt like I had been magically transported back into England of the 1940s, living the life of a Bletchley Park cryptanalyst. I didn't want to leave the world Michael Apted and his cast and crew had created, which is surely the sign of a great film.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
26 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Worth watching but don't think this is the real story, 4 Aug 2007
This review is from: Enigma [DVD] [2001] (DVD)
I was so looking forward to this film as I have for many years been fascinated by the story of Bletchley Park. I also love Robert Harris' novel "Enigma" on which this film is partly based.
I was disappointed because I have read something of the backgound and found the short cuts taken for the purposes of the screenplay very clumsy, for example the explanation about why the U-boat codes couldn't be read and taking an Enigma machine away, just misrepresented the technicalities and the real drama and difficulty of what people were doing.
If I hadn't known what the story of code-breaking was really about, I would have really enjoyed this film and there is a lot to like. Kate Winslet is well-cast and is good in the role of Hester. Jeremy Northam is wonderfully chilling. Dougray Scott uses a strange array of accents but is endearing. There is one scene which captures the tension, when the codebreakers spend the night trying to reconstruct their "crib" in order to break the code and that is very well done. The whole film is well made, I think.
So, in summary, this an odd adaptation of a book which itself tries to tell a true story by means of fiction. It's all a bit techie so that was always going to be difficult.
Watch it as a latter-day John Buchan story. It's a fun film.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An enjoyable story set around Bletchley Park in WW2, 28 Oct 2008
This review is from: Enigma [DVD] [2001] (DVD)
If I had wanted a documentary about Bletchley Park during WW2, I would have bought one of several good titles available, or a DVD if there was one.
Want I wanted, and got, was a really good fictional account set around the code breaking activities of that centre. The story is loosely based on real characters and events, but it is a STORY, and a very enjoyably told and terrifically acted one. I like all the actors, they work well together. The story is plausible, but I'm not interested in 'is this or that detail correct', I just want a good hour or two of entertainment set in the period of WW2, around that unique institution, and I was well satisfied.
I cannot understand why people have to nitpick. Its not as if anyone is deliberately setting out to 'distort history'; there's no harm in giving a little fictional leeway here and there. The main thrust of the story is sound, and enjoyably told, so 5 stars.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|