28 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A lovely book but ....., 10 Mar 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: England's Thousand Best Churches (Paperback)
This is in many ways an excellent book, the photographs wonderful and the writing, as others have commented, very much a la Pevsner at his pithy best. ... brass rhubarb for the unhelpful keyholder at Dorney, Bucks. indeed - marvellous!
I do, however, have three criticisms:
The first is to do with the book's organisation. Given the ever-increasing fluidity of modern administrative boundaries, which ebb and flow seemingly with each successive Local Government Act, why not use ALL the old, historic, pre-1965/1974 county boundaries, still largely adhered to in the Buildings of England series? Granted we are presented with the recently recreated Rutland and Herefordshire, and even the long-departed Huntingdonshire, so why do we still have to suffer that amorphous lump of "Cumbria", or "North Yorkshire", instead of dealing with the three historic ridings, or the indignity of lovely West Riding churches treated under, horror of horrors, Lancashire.
It may be pertinent that Mr Jenkins has seen fit to go by the old counties in southern England but not in the north and that brings me to my second grumble, namely a slight but still discernable southern bias. We all know that Somerset and Norfolk have outstanding church architecture but so too, as Mr J admits himself, does Yorkshire. So why is it that there are so many more entries for the former than for his "N Yorks" section? And as for Northumberland and "Cumbria", so scanty is the coverage I'm left seriously questioning whether his journeyings actually took him up the A1 much past Wetherby.
Quibble three is that, ex-Anglican or not, there is a wee bit too much concentration on the fourth rate C of E to the exclusion of some first rate Catholic and especially Nonconformist buildings. Yes, Cheadle and Walpole and Tewkesbury Old Baptist are there, but I sought in vane for Newbiggin (Durham), the World's oldest Methodist chapel, or Brigflatts or Colthouse Meeting Houses, and where is the National Trust's lovely Loughwood in Devon?
That said, Simon Jenkins has given us a very fine book and I do hope that he may manage a sequel. Might I be so bold as to suggest a companion 1000 covering the other home countries, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, plus the Isle of Man and the Channel Islands? But please, if you're reading this Mr J, can we have Radnorshire and Sutherland and not "Powys" and "Highland"?!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful, 29 Jan 2012
This review is from: England's Thousand Best Churches (Paperback)
I love this book. I bought it many years ago and treasure it still. I feel alienated by organised religion, but I have a passion for church architecture and the feelings that these churches possess. They're our heritage, our social history, they're art, they appeal to the soul, they're the essence of whatever we are on these isles and Simon Jenkins has recorded them so beautifully and so exactly while maintaining their enigmatic quality. This is a very important record. A very personal record. Even a significant record of our best churches. Thank you Simon Jenkins.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
opened my eyes, 16 Jun 2011
This review is from: England's Thousand Best Churches (Paperback)
I was interested in church architecture as a young man, but had rather got out of the way of it as I got older. This book, along with a couple by Alec Clifton-Taylor, opened my eyes to the wonders that are out there. Simon Jenkins is generous to the best Victorian churches (quite rightly) and is incisive and as committed as it is possible to be when writing about so many diverse buildings. A book we needed, never mind the odd inaccuracy, or flip opinion about particular towns (there is one about my home town, but it has an element of truth about it).
And I am still proud of having got into St Augustine's, Pendlebury, which he never managed - one of the really great Victorian churches.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No