Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A little more time., 27 Oct 2006
I wish Kate Williams had waited a little before publishing this book. She is clearly clever and enthusiastic, and sympathetic to a woman who has had more than her fair share of denigration over the years. The weakness of the book, I think is that she makes unsubstantiated conjectures about Emma's life, based on the general social conditions of the period, which are not sustainable and are more suited to an historical novel than a biography. Nevertheless, there are some interesting insights here - such as the assertion, without quoting sources, that Nelson knew about Emma's earlier illegitimate daughter. There are some grounds, but no concrete evidence, for this view. Other Nelson scholars such as Colin White and Tom Pocock do speculate on possibility, but always grounded in known circumstance, and had Kate Williams handled this, and other matters, in a more tentative way, her narrative would, paradoxically, have carried more weight.
I found the background material of the demi-monde and the observations on the cult of celebrity interesting and informative. I just wish Ms Williams, as a young, keen writer, had had better guidance from her publishers and editors. As it is, the book is part novel, part pop-biography aiming to be a serious academic work. The result is a confusion of genres which is unsatisfying.If only she had allowed her insights and ideas to ripen for a while she could have added more considered reflection and a more polished writing style to her enthusiasm and sympathy. The result would have been a deeper, richer book.
|
|
|
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A really good read , 23 Oct 2006
I listened to the radio 4 extracts from this book and have now just finished reading it.
I must confess that, having met the author and having seen her on TV a couple of times I was already predisposed to like this book and it did not disappoint me. I may be biased but Kate Williams is a very intelligent and attractive young woman who writes in an easy style that communicates both her love of the subject and her detailed knowledge of the period.
Although I know that the author is a highly qualified academic and that she has done several years of research to produce this book what really struck me was the way she brought the period and Emma's background and experiences to life. I cannot claim to have read widely about Emma Hamilton but I now feel that I understand her and the extraordinary life she lead. One can think of a number of current celebrities who have used looks, charm and nerve to gain access to a better life but few can compare with what Emma Hamilton experienced and achieved. I thoroughly recommend this book - a very enjoyable and informative read.
|
|
|
7 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
History That's as Compulsively Readable as a Novel, 1 Nov 2006
Not every historical biography is as compulsively readable as this. If they were a lot of school children would be much more happy.
Many biographies claim to be as compelling and fascinating to read as novels, but I can't recall a single other biography I've read that's lived up to that very big claim. Kate Williams manages to strike the perfect tone between the feel of fiction prose and an informative and engaging history lesson. She grabs the reader immediately, partly due to the fact her subject is, to put it mildly, an interesting figure. But it's more than that. Williams writes in such an approachable style, and it's probably what I'd consider the absolute perfect style for writing a historical biography. There are no places interest flags in this book, so perfectly has Williams paced the material. From start to finish it's as gripping to read as the best literary novels, and it's made all the more fascinating knowing every word of it is true.
As for Lady Emma Hamilton herself, what a woman! Whether you think her bold and courageous or a gold-digging tramp, you have to give the lady credit for having her wits about her. She reminds me of Daniel Defoe's Moll Flanders, though Moll never hit the big time the way Emma did. Moll was crafty, it's true, but lacking the stunning beauty and obvious and unflagging street smarts of Emma. As far as fictional characters go, though, I think Moll would be as near the mark as they come.
What an amazing cast of real-life historical characters pepper this book. Not really knowing much of the hard history behind Lady Emma's life, I didn't realize her relationship with Admiral Nelson beforehand. That very likely made me even more riveted to the book, but I can't imagine any fiction being any more compelling than the truth of this woman's life. What a lot of cheek, on the one hand, but what a brilliant use of her resources, too. And I DO mean all her resources...
Whether you end up loving or reviling the woman, it's inarguable that she was hugely influential in 18th century society. How much she actually did help write history could be debated, but I'd personally be willing to bet her imprint was vastly influential. After all, the woman had the ear of so many of the elite, not to mention the heart of the national hero. Her moral scruples may not have been enviable, but her cunning is something if not to admire, at least to acknowledge as being very much out of the ordinary. However you feel about Lady Emma going into the book, by the time you're done you'll have had such a good history lesson, and an entertaining one at that, you'll ultimately know how you stand on the issue. Kate Williams presents all the facts without prejudice, and with such a flair, there will be no lukewarm reaction.
I can't imagine anyone who loves to read well-written historical prose, whether fiction or non-fiction, wouldn't find something in this book. Whether your genre is fiction, biography or history this book fits the bill. It's simply one of the most impressive, and satisfying, first efforts I've ever seen, and I can only hope Kate Williams is working on a follow-up book.
It's been a while since I've been this smitten with a work of biography, and I came away with so much more knowledge on the 18th century, a topic I already thought I knew a bit about having spent a good deal of time reading the fiction of that period, and also a burning desire to read everything else that's out there on the topic of Lady Emma Hamilton. However, whatever else I do wind up reading I know I'll consider Williams' work the benchmark by which I judge the sheer readability of the other works. The simple fact is, a book's readability determines its appeal, and judged by this England's Mistress is one of the absolute best works of biography I have ever read.
Well done, Kate Williams!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Kate Williams
by Kate Williams
![Apocalypse Now [1979] [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41P41PPXH2L._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Martin Sheen
by Hilary Mantel
by Stephen Robinson
