31 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Wrong Enemy: A dark chapter brought to light., 11 Sep 2009
This review is from: England's Last War Against France: Fighting Vichy 1940-42 (Hardcover)
Smith's great skill is to illuminate a complex passage of history with strong, clear narrative, brought to life with a profusion of human detail. The war against Vichy France is often treated as a grim footnote to the larger story of the second world war. It was, after all, fought against what one of the protagonists quoted by Smith exactly described as the 'wrong enemy', so it is hardly surprising that it receives less attention than it deserves. Now we have a detailed and brilliantly assembled account in which the reader gets a clear understanding of the historical context and a real sense of what it might have been like to have been involved. As in all the best narratives, the people are brought vividly to life by Smith's sharp eye for human detail, supplemented by generous quotations from eye witnesses.
A thoroughly good read and a very worthwhile contribution to the understanding of one of the darker strands of the complicated relationship between France and England.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Englands last war against France, 5 Oct 2009
This review is from: England's Last War Against France: Fighting Vichy 1940-42 (Hardcover)
Most readers will have their own predetermined views
regarding relationships with the French, as the French will
have with the English. But Smith has assembled a
definitive and impartial account of a very contentious era
with France and England. What he has achieved is an
invitation for us all, English and French, to have a better
in depth understanding of those dark and difficult days of
1940/42.
After outlining the making of the Entente Cordiale in
the first decades of the 20th century, his story starts
first with the Royal Navy's failure to prevent Germany's
invasion of Norway then the French view that Dunkirk's
British Expeditionary Force was in reality little more than
an ill equipped, token army. The defeat of the Allies and
the French surrender was irredeemable. This left the
powerful French navy available for ownership and culminated
in Admiral Somerville's reluctant sinking, with
great loss of life, of his recent allies at Mers el-Kebir .
These events triggered the Vichy French breaking of
diplomatic relations and telegraphed to the world that
England, despite the formidable odds, would never make peace
with Hitler and was prepared to fight on.
Smith possesses the unrivalled ability of maintaining the readers
interest to the point of obsession, and has successfully
resurrected the campaigns of Syria and Madagascar drawing
from the experiences of living participants with vivid first
hand accounts of the kind you rarely find in duller
historical tomes. This is a truly remarkable book
summarising what really took place: a breach of trust
involving both countries.
Jack Riches
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
England's Last War Against France, 14 Oct 2009
This review is from: England's Last War Against France: Fighting Vichy 1940-42 (Hardcover)
I found this an extremely interesting book, particularly for the period when France was initially occupied by the Nazi Germany. The boarding of the French submarine in Portsmouth Harbour and the subsequent loss of life was very revealing about French attitudes to the British at the time, indeed the whole book raised some uncomfortable issues regarding the hostility of some French towards this country.
The campaigns against the Vichy French in Africa were detailed and exciting, but my abiding thought was that so many French and British soldiers lives had been unnecessarily lost.
Prior to reading this book I thought I had a good understanding about World War II, however I was woefully ignorant of most of the events described in this book and although it made, at times, for disturbing reading it was a thoroughly worthwhile read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No