To be fair, my grandson is allergic to eggs, wheat, gluten and dairy. So it's really a feat to make anything that works and tastes anything like normal food! So approaching his first birthday I figured I'd try and make various cakes and muffins. Unfortunately, nothing really worked. Before I had the egg replacer, other substitutes I tried left the results too crumbly to eat. The egg replacer made it look great - but the results were like rubber and very sticky and pale. If others have good experiences then maybe it's the combination of this with strange flours etc, but to me it was a disappointment and it doesn't make me want to try baking with it again any time soon. I find that using mashed banana is actually the best replacement for eggs in cakes.