Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Mean streets..., 25 Jan 2012
In his office, a shabby, ex hotel room, lit by the orange glare from the street sits a PI, waiting for his next client. Hidden in a basement nearby is Jerry's, the speakeasy where he spents his spare time: at the back of the office is a tiny bedroom where he sleeps. Welcome to the Empire State, a twisted projection of 1930s New York, isolated in its own "pocket universe" and created when... but that would be a spoiler. Christopher's novel flits back and forth between Empire State and New York proper - a New York where superheroes battle amidst the mobsters and corrupt judges. As if the Chandleresque PI and superheroes weren't enough, we have robots, goggles and and airships (and fog) - so it's kind of SF-ish, noir steampunk-lite, if you're still trying to find the right pigeonhole - but I don't think one really exists. All of which gives the book, especially the first half, a wonderful atmosphere, as Rad (the PI) investigates a case brought to him by a smartly turned out young woman (of couse) - but with a twist I won't, again, give away. Cue a breakneck trip through the murky world of the Empire State, confused by (and intercut with) those superheroes, a shady preacher, hoodlums in gas masks and a great deal else. It's enchanting, wonderful, and the pages keep turning. However, I was disappointed by the ending. Like an Agatha Cristie story, pretty much everyone is gathered together (albeit in a Government warehouse, not a cosy library). In around 20 pages, plot is explained, alliances are made, broken and reformed and characters clash in various combinations. It was alla bit too much, a bit too intense; some of these characters are hard to tell apart - again, I won't say why (spoilers!) and, by the time I reached the end, I felt I'd lost most of my sense of what had really been going on. A degree of double (and triple) crossing and confusion one thing, but I just wasn't convinced by all the twists and turns. That aside, this is an atmospheric, enthralling and (n places) funny book - there is a running joke about Rad losing his hat, which might not sound funny, but by the end, is - and lots of allusions to pulp classics. But for the ending, I'd give this four stars but as it is, i think that three is right. But despite that, this is well worth a read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Super atmospheric noir novel, 21 Dec 2011
One of the most buzzed about debuts for 2012, ever since it was announced, Adam Christopher's Empire State is a much anticipated release around the blogosphere. Normally not given to reading superhero novels or comic books, I do enjoy a good noir detective, so I was curious to read the book and see why everyone was so excited about this book. While I really enjoyed the story, I did have some issues with it, but I do understand the buzz for Empire State. What stands out most in this book are the atmosphere Christopher creates and the world building, which was very well done. You can feel the fog and the rain; see the gritty, yellowish light of the Empire State. The Prohibition vibe was laced through everything. I also really liked the idea of an alternate dimension NYC. The idea of doubles being created in this alternate dimension was pretty cool and I liked the way the author played with this conceit. What also spoke from the atmosphere and world building was Christopher's love for New York City, he lovingly paints its picture and that of the Empire State. In fact, the writing was such that I think the book would make for an excellent film, with leeched colours and lots of rain! The character of Rad was well drawn; I really liked his everyman, good guy outlook, even though he is a bit of a PI gone to seed. He gives the reader a hook to understand what's going on, because he's discovering these facts for himself, thus for the most part staying away from the dreaded info dump. The secondary characters were good too, especially Captain Carson. I really liked this old gentleman and his companion Byron. I thought he was interesting and his back story would make for interesting reading as well, though by the end of the book, for reasons I'll explain later, he became a little exasperating to me. Much has been made of the superhero angle of the book, but to me they were the characters that came to the fore and to life the least. For most of the book they just seemed the means to an end - to give us a reason for the Empire State - only at the end of the book does their role really interact with the narrative. My main issues with the book were that for me it was a bit of a slow starter - it took me a while to get into the story - and the last few chapters. During the last part of the book, there are lots of crosses, double-crosses and triple-crosses and at one point I just lost track and felt a little worn out by it all. Even though by the wrap up of the novel, it all made sense, during those last chapters I just felt needlessly confused and started rolling my eyes whenever people switched sides. I could have done with a few less switches and a more straight-forward denouement of the novel. Then again, your mileage may vary on this point, as I'm convinced there will be lots of people who will love the complexity of those final chapters, but for me, it didn't work very well. In the end though, despite my reservations stipulated above, I had a really good time with Empire State. I really liked Rad and wanted to know how his story ended and when an author succeeds in investing me in a character that much, he's done his job well. I personally hope the book will be optioned for a film, because I think that would make for a fantastic flick! If you like a good noir tale, Empire State is a book you won't want to miss. For a full on superhero book, you might want to wait for Christopher's next novel, Seven Wonders, due out from Angry Robot Books in September 2012. Empire State will be released next Tuesday, December 27th, though it has already been spotted out in the wild! This book was provided for review by the publisher.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
It's not Hardboiled; It's Deviled-egg!, 22 Dec 2011
Empire State is an extremely accomplished debut from Angry Robot. Rad Bradley is a private detective in the Empire State, which is a strange, alternate totalitarian New York. It's wrapped in eternal fog and has almost been frozen in time in the 1930s-Prohibition Era. No one dares ask to many questions about what lays beyond the fog, or else they have a way of disappearing. Meanwhile, in a New York almost like our own, another man names Rex stumbles upon a mystery of his own. What these two cities have in common are two superheroes who are at odds. Empire State is a noir mystery with alternate dimensions, superheroes, robots, airships, a cult, goons in gas masks, and lots of fog and rain and secrets. The setting of the two cities are palpable. Christopher's writing has a very visual style, and I imagined it as an old film or a comic book. Empire State is eerie and hazy. The Empire State also made me think it was a commentary on the different approaches America could have taken to wartime--The Empire State is America isolationism at its finest, locked in perpetual war with an un-named Other. If you're a fan of Chandler and the classic noir, then you'll like Empire State. Rad channels a bit of Marlowe, if Marlowe was a black past boxer in Prohibition-era alternate New York with robots instead of 1930s Los Angeles. My favourite scene was when the stereotypical posh, put-together young woman sashays into Rad's office, but the expectation is turned on its head when Rad realizes just who she's asking him to search for. Empire State flirts with the conventions of past mysteries, but gives each element a subtle twist. There's a lot of secondary characters and all have their own plot arcs, such as Captain Carson and Kane Fortuna and the City Commissioner. Rad is dragged into a mystery that goes deeper than he could have imagined, resulting in twisted doppelgangers, people who change allegiance at the drop of a white fedora, and the discovery of a strange, other place called New York. While I loved the atmosphere and the plotting and the writing, I did have some minor quibbles. The story did start a little slowly and it took me a bit of time to get a feel for Rad as a character. Additionally, there's a decided lack of female character screen-time, which is a bit of a shame. I would have liked to know a lot more about Kopek and Saturn. The end was complicated and it was difficult to keep track of the characters and what side they were on, but I managed just fine, though I did find myself going back and re-reading to make sure I understood events properly when it would have been better to not interrupt the flow. Overall, it's an excellent book, and if you like comics, the TV show Fringe, and pulpy hardboiled mysteries, then this is a book to pick up.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|