Empire of Glass (New Doctor Who Missing Adventures) [Paperback]

Whilst I agree with some of the previous reviewer's comments I actually enjoyed this offering from Andy Lane. Although the plot is banal it is a faithful re-creation of the type of adventure the 1st Doctor would have been caught up in. It also actually develops the rather anodyne TV depictions of Steven and Vicky and gives them - particularly Steven - some more character and action. I thought that Kit Marlowe's attempts to seduce Steven were a rather odd element of the story; Steven himself appears to be questioning his feelings by the end; very strange.
All-in-all an easy and enjoyable read; certainly not the worst of the Missing Adventures by a long chalk.

Over the course of the last couple of years Andy Lane has established himself as one of my favourite "Doctor Who" novelists. Somewhat remarkably, I've found that he's able to tell both futuristic space operas and meticulously researched pseudo-historical stories with the same level of skill. Just look at "All-Consuming Fire" and "Original Sin" - two of the very best novels in the whole Virgin catalogue, yet poles apart. "The Empire of Glass", however, was nothing like I'd expected it to be.

It's far from being a bad novel - if anything, it's bundles of fun. I think old William Hartnell serials the likes of "The Reign of Terror" and "The Romans", as opposed to the more serious historicals like "The Aztecs" and "The Massacre", must have influenced Lane as "The Empire of Glass" is a book that has its tongue firmly planted in its cheek throughout. William Shakespeare, Christopher Marlowe, Galileo Galilei, even Irving Braxiatel. Real or fictional, human or Time Lord, this novel is packed to bursting with larger than life characters.

However, in marked contrast to his previous novels, Lane's plot is actually rather thin. The basic idea is interesting enough - Braxiatel holding a big galactic disarmament conference above Venice in 1609 - but things tend to move along not only at a snail's pace, but also rather predictably.

It says a lot about the book that the parts which interested me the most were those that related to the larger mythology rather than the stand-alone story. Here we learn that the first Doctor that we see in "The Three Doctors" was lifted out of time by the Time Lords between "The Time Meddler" and "Galaxy Four," and that after giving counsel to his future selves in that serial he had a few minutes to spare; got chatting with fellow Gallifreyan Braxiatel; and ended up being invited to chair his conference. Oh, and then he got his memory wiped and forgot all about it. The writer has clearly had great fun playing about with the show's continuity, but he has done it in a way that if, for example, you were reading this book as part of the Hartnell era, then it would still make sense as Lane gives away no secrets about the Time Lords, who at that time were yet to be named in the series - they are only referred to as the Doctor and Braxiatel's people. Furthermore, the events of "The Three Doctors" are not alluded to directly; it is only when one is familiar with later events that these little touches make sense in the larger context.

Braxiatel himself is interesting to read about here, particularly when he spars verbally with the cantankerous old Doctor. However, it is in his handling of Steven and Vicki that Lane truly excels. With Vicki, he explores her thoughts and feelings about her father's death and her life on Dido, none of which was even touched upon on television. And as for Steven, Lane goes one further. Not content to merely explore the long-term effects that have grown out of his lonely incarceration on Mechanus, the author goes into great detail as to the specifics of the war that Steven fought against the Krayt which led to his fateful crash-landing there. He also turns Steven gay. Yep; you read it right - Steven and Marlowe come close to getting it on. I wonder what Peter Purves would have said about that, hmm?

And so despite lacking the wow factor of earlier Lane efforts, "The Empire of Glass" is rather a nice little novel. It's an atmospheric and light-hearted romp - nothing more, nothing less - and should be enjoyed exactly as such.

Originally published on "The History of the Doctor," 2006. Reproduced with kind permission.

The Empire of Glass has all the ingredients to be a success: The 1st Doctor, Vicki, Steven, 17th Century Venice, William Shakespeare, Christopher Marlowe, Galileo, Braxiatel and umpteen alien races, but it falls flat due to it's terminally boring plot. The entire first half of the novel is padding, with the Doctor getting involved in a case of mistaken identity - when the plot is finally revealed it turns out to be a very bland tale of an alien arms limitation conference set up by rogue Time Lord Braxiatel. The characters and settings are vivid, but the storyline is so dull and lacking in dramatic tension you'll find it very difficult to care about. One for the completists only.