| ||
| Song Title | Time | Price | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Play | 1. Annihilation | 2:13 | £0.89 | ||
| Play | 2. Imagine | 4:48 | £0.89 | ||
| Play | 3. Peace Love and Understanding | 5:03 | £0.89 | ||
| Play | 4. What's Going On | 4:53 | £0.89 | ||
| Play | 5. Passive [Explicit] | 4:09 | £0.89 | ||
| Play | 6. Gimme Gimme Gimme | 2:18 | £0.89 | ||
| Play | 7. People Are People | 3:42 | £0.89 | ||
| Play | 8. Freedom of Choice | 2:59 | £0.89 | ||
| Play | 9. Let's Have A War | 3:28 | £0.89 | ||
| Play | 10. Counting Bodies Like Sheep To The Rhythm Of The War Drums [Explicit] | 5:35 | £0.89 | ||
| Play | 11. When The Levee Breaks | 5:55 | £0.89 | ||
| Play | 12. Fiddle And The Drum | 3:06 | £0.89 |
Product details
|
If it was any standard album then it'd be a fairly decent attempt at an alternative take on a fairly random assortment of tunes. The problem lies in the fact that A Perfect Circle's own material has a very distinctive atmosphere and style behind it and in trying to apply it to some of these other songs, it fails.
I would stress at this point that there are a number of very good renditions on here.
The good? The Annihilation - anathemic but nicely done. Peace Love and Understanding - takes a while to get going, but the usage of strings works nicely and the song suits Maynard's voice. Counting Bodies Like Sheep to the Rhythm of the War Drums - this comes across as a version of Pet if i has been written by NiN. I personally really like it - although as a song in it's own right, as the style is so much less flowing than the original.
The not so bad? Imagine - as much as I've heard it, I still like the orginal. This version is far more discordant than the original and drags it's feet a little, but the overall effect isn't bad. Lets Have a War - moves nicely.
The ugly? Gimme Gimme Gimme. In my opinion, it simply doesn't work.
The rest of the tunes are.....pleasant, but none of them stand out - and this is where the problem lies. Mer De Noms, or more recently Thirteenth Step have a lot more feeling and drive behind them. Whilst the style is still noticably A Perfect Circle every other part of this band that I like is lacking. Whereas Mer De Noms was at least a collection of songs with similar style and intention behind them and Thirteenth Step came across more as parts of a story banded together, this one doesn't involve the listener.
Give it a listen, you'll probably enjoy a fair bit of it. It really depends whether you know the orignals or not.
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|