I read this book at least 10 years ago, and had forgotten about it. Then recently there was someone with the name of Emmeline on television - no relation in any way, but it made me think of the book. I remembered the storyline and thought it unique, so I check Amazon, and of course, it was available. (And BTW, the book was advertised as "used", and I paid less than a dollar for it, but it was brand new.) :-)
All the other reviewers have done a great job of reviewing it, and I can't add to it, and only have one other observation. The first time I read it, I was so incredibly sad for Emmeline and felt depressed for days. Books do that to me sometimes. But now, years later, after reading it, altho' I'm still sympathetic, I was a bit annoyed at Emmeline. Both as a 13/14 year old, and as an adult. I know the attitudes of the times were outrageous.....like "confining" a pregnant woman when she started to show -- things like that. But I just wanted to shake Emmeline. I got a bit too tired of her intense "devotion" to Mr. Maguire, and then later to Matthew. Once she made up her mind, that was IT. I just found her a bit tiring now that I'm older and have grandchildren of my own. Still a good read, though.