Eminem may well be one of the greatest rappers ever. Despite the less than stellar Encore album being his last proper album to date, his reputation is already cemented based on its three predecessors and he will forever be remembered for that. Then why does he choose to surround himself with such mediocre peers?
Em's crew, which takes in the ultra-offensive D12, 50 Cent's mostly awful G-Unit and the likes of newcomers like Bobby Creekwater, all pile into this mixtape-a-like album that doesn't really gain Eminem much ground following Encore. This isn't an Eminem album, this is an album that is executive produced by Eminem, and quite frankly, production is not Marshall Mathers' strong suit. His basslines and beats are almost always far too weak and his taste for octave vocals grates after a while, but here we are with almost a whole album produced by him.
Coupled with the death of Proof, this album was made under less than auspicious circumstances. In hindsight, it's probably about as good as it could be considering. Too many of the songs - D12's 'Murder,' the title track and the late Proof's contribution - sound like sketches or weak filler for the individuals' own albums and as previously mentioned, Eminem's production is often uninspired. Even his own rhymes are below par, as while his multi-faceted, intricate style melds effortlessly to all of these beats, he doesn't really mention a great deal of his recent life events, which could all have made for fascinating listening.
Luckily, the album's not a complete bust. Fantastic lead single 'You Don't Know' is probably the album's best song, its thudding drums and party atmosphere a welcome change to the otherwise fairly grey atmosphere. 'Jimmy Crack Corn' isn't too bad either, hopping along on a sprightly beat that matches its name, though 50 Cent's rapping lets it down. Almost as good as 'You Don't Know' is 'There He Is' by the relatively unknown Bobby Creekwater. A masterful, psychedelic production laden with samples (which by the way, sounds totally out of place here) backs his unfortunately slightly generic rhymes.
All in all, this is really only a necessary purchase for a hardcore Eminem fan. Otherwise, you may as well not bother, becuase this is far from essential listening.