Scott Matthews' debut album was always going to be a tough act to follow, but with "Elsewhere", I'm in no doubt that he has more than equalled his breakthrough album, being a darker, more mature and ultimately more satisfying follow-up. With a knack for writing songs which would fit onto any Nick Drake album and yet delivering them like a more the tortured love child of Eddie Vedder and Jeff Buckley, Matthews' performance of these tracks alone is enough to make this album remarkable, but the depth and meaning of the work is what really makes this release a real gem. The first track, "Underlying Lies" is an absolutely magnificent composition, starting subtly and building to it's string-laden, spine-tingling climax, with lyrics echoing the bitterness of betrayal. "Jagged Melody" is devastatingly beautiful, a song seemingly composed for someone who is suffering from depression. "Fractured" is another brilliant song on the same theme, with Matthews displaying the strain of having to pull someone out of the mire. The sublime "12 Harps" finds Matthews duetting with fellow Black Country legend Robert Plant with gorgeously emotive results.
Another undoubted highlight of the album is "Speeding Slowly", the story of a disintegrating relationship which, musically, reminds me a little of Pearl Jam at their melodic best. "Into The Firing Line" is probably the most commercial track on the whole release, but it is still a very classy and thoughtful song which tackles armchair supporters of military action. The sadly longing "Up On The Hill" also hits an emotional chord and reminds me of the late, great Elliott Smith, whereas the regretful, folk-tinted "Fades In Vain" could be one of Boo Hewerdine's recent pieces of excellence. This superb album is concluded by the delicate strains of "Nothing's Quite Right Here", a beautiful ending to a brilliant piece of work.
It is certainly true that "Elsewhere" is a melancholy album which covers many introspective, difficult subjects which some people will find difficult to deal with. It is also true that you will not reveal everything this album has to offer with one listen, it's way more intricate than that, but persistence has many rewards in the case of Matthews' second. Naturally, if your favourite artist is Mika or Mariah Carey then this album probably won't push your particular buttons. However, for those whose idea of artistry is hearing a beautifully sculpted, expressive collection of songs which encompass a wide range of human emotions, then Scott Matthews has made an incredible album which will most definitely appeal to you. One of the very best albums of the year.