This has been my favorite Ella Fitzgerald set since I first acquired the vinyl in 1975 or so. The editorial review leads you to believe that these tracks are derived from the eight- disc boxed set, but that's not accurate - THIS is the original album, and all that was available of these wonderful concerts for many years. I was excited when they announced the release of the eight disc boxed set, knowing how much I love the music on the original two disc set, but in retrospect, the big box set doesn't really contain much more worthwhile material. If I had to do it over I would just buy the two-disc set and skip buying the box, as I find myself playing this one over and over and hardly ever cracking open the other.
The selections presented on this two-disc set are definitely the cream of the crop. I strongly disagree with those who say that Ella shines here but Duke is only so-so. Ella's tracks are of course magnificent, but Duke leads the band with great skill and perfect timing, as he always does. And as a singer, his scatting on "It Don't Mean a Thing" is quite brilliant. He is not as polished as Ella, but he does manage to match her vitality, even as he strains for some of the notes. And in terms of improvisation, he actually catches her off-guard more than once, and I find myself smiling with each "shoe-be-do-ba-dua" that he lets out. I always find it hard to sit still as I listen to him growl, and sometimes I dance around the room when his vocal really gets going. My CD collection contains not quite enough Duke Ellington (14 CD's) and maybe too much Ella Fitzgerald (97 CD's - but then, can one really have TOO much Ella?) but if I had to pick just one album to take on a permanent vacation, this would be it. The two big swing numbers, Mack the Knife and It Don't Mean a Thing are possibly my pick as the most "fun" pieces, but there really isn't a weak moment on the whole album. Ella's reading of the ballads Misty and How Long Has This Been Going On are absolutely perfect, and her Lullaby of Birdland is probably my favorite track on the album. The three extra tracks from the eight-disc box are nothing special, and quite representative of what that set contains. Those seeking a complete record of these concerts will do alright by purchasing the larger boxed set, but I think this album contains all that's really essential. Either way, this music is quite entertaining, and highly recommended.