Amazon.co.uk Review
Starkey argues that in her first 25 years Elizabeth "had experienced every vicissitude of fortune and ever extreme of condition. She had been Princess and inheritrix of England, and bastard and disinherited; the nominated successor to the throne and an accused traitor on the verge of execution; showered with lands and houses and a prisoner in the Tower". He draws on his skills as a respected Tudor historian to produce a deft account of the religious, political and dynastic maelstrom of mid-16th century England that reads "like a historical thriller". The book carefully picks its way through the finer points of contemporary religious conflict and the peculiarities of Tudor court ceremony, whilst also exploring the formation of Elizabeth's character in relation to a murdered mother, a charismatic father, a tortured sister, and a predatory guardian. Highly readable and written with verve and pace, this is a fascinating account of the young Elizabeth. --Jerry Brotton --This text refers to an alternate Hardcover edition.
Review
Book Description
Product Description
A brilliant and compelling account of the apprentice years of Elizabeth I.
An abused child, yet confident of her destiny to reign, a woman in a man’s world, passionately sexual yet – she said – a virgin, Elizabeth I was to be famed as England’s most successful ruler. This absorbing new book, by concentrating on the early years from her birth in 1533 to her accession in 1558, shows how her experiences of danger and adventure formed her remarkable character and shaped her opinions and beliefs.
For in her youth she had experienced every vicissitude of fortune and every extreme of condition. She had been Princess and inheritrix of England – then bastardized and disinherited. At sixteen she was the head of a great princely household. Not much later she was an accused traitor on the verge of execution in the Tower. Among all this, she had been taught the most advanced curriculum of the day. But it was her lessons in the school of life that mattered more – and that taught her humanity.
Dr David Starkey recreates a host of extravagant characters, mad-cap schemes and tragic plots, while using original documents to point up the importance of the rituals of power and life at court. He writes with admirable clarity about religion and constitutional history. This brilliant book contrasts the daughters of Henry VIII: the pious Catholic Mary and her clever sister. The key to understanding Elizabeth is her determination not to make the same mistakes as Mary.
From the Publisher
From the Back Cover
An abused child, yet confident of her destiny to reign, a woman in a man’s world, passionately sexual yet – she said – a virgin, Elizabeth I was to be famed as England’s most successful ruler. This absorbing new book, by concentrating on the early years from her birth in 1533 to her accession in 1558, shows how her experiences of danger and adventure formed her remarkable character and shaped her opinions and beliefs.
For in her youth she had experienced every vicissitude of fortune and every extreme of condition. She had been Princess and inheritrix of England – then bastardized and disinherited. At sixteen she was the head of a great princely household. Not much later she was an accused traitor on the verge of execution in the Tower. Among all this, she had been taught the most advanced curriculum of the day. But it was her lessons in the school of life that mattered more – and that taught her humanity.
Dr David Starkey recreates a host of extravagant characters, mad-cap schemes and tragic plots, while using original documents to point up the importance of the rituals of power and life at court. He writes with admirable clarity about religion and constitutional history. This brilliant book contrasts the daughters of Henry VIII: the pious Catholic Mary and her clever sister. The key to understanding Elizabeth is her determination not to make the same mistakes as Mary.
About the Author
David Starkey is Honorary Fellow of Fitzwilliam College, Cambridge, and the author of many books including ‘Elizabeth’; ‘Six Wives: The Queens of Henry VIII’ and ‘Monarchy: England and Her Rulers from the Tudors to the Windsors’. He is a winner of the WH Smith Prize and the Norton Medlicott Medal for Services to History presented by Britain’s Historical Association. He is a well-known TV and radio personality. He was made a CBE in 2007. He lives in London.
Excerpted from Elizabeth I: The Exhibition Catalogue by Starkey David, Susan Doran. Copyright © 2003. Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.
What we have in this portrait is the teenager who formed the woman. And one of the most important things about the Exhibition is that it deals with this teenager and with her formative experience. So we do not just look at Gloriana, at the painted mask of her Final artificiality. We do not just look at the glory days of the latter part of the reign. We also look, long and hard, at the brutal experience of her youth.
This means that, when we open the Catalogue or go into the Exhibition galleries, the first thing we see is not an exquisite painting by Hilliard, not a confectionery-dress, nor some frou-frou, but an armour for man and horse (see page 1). It is beautifully decorated with the characteristic gold inlaid borders of the best Greenwich armour. But it is not a parade armour, but the real, working armour of one of the power-brokers of the middle of the sixteenth century, William Herbert, 1st Earl of Pembroke. It is astonishing, brutal, like the mounted statue of an Italian condottiere.
And the man inside it fully lived up to the image. Herbert committed at least two murders in his youth. But he was twice pardoned by Elizabeths father, Henry VIII. Indeed, impressed it is said by his performance in a sword-fight outside Whitehall, Henry took him into his household. There he rose rapidly. He married Anne Parr which made him, in the fullness of time, brother-in-law of Henry VIIIs last queen, Catherine Parr. And he became Chief Gentleman of the privy chamber, or joint-principal body servant of the King. As such, he witnessed Henrys almost-certainly doctored Will, which gave him a substantial legacy and made him a member of the young King Edward VIs privy council. Here he proved as grimly dextrous in politics as he was with the sword. He backed Northumberland against Somerset and was rewarded with an earldom. Then, after Edwards death, he threw over Northumberland and Northumberlands creature, Lady Jane Grey, and informed his demoralised fellow-councillors!
: either this sword shall make Mary Queen or Ill lose my life.
He was as good as his word and was, effectively, Marys queen-maker. And he showed a similar bold determination in the other crises of the 1550s, such as Wyatts revolt, when he was Marys most effective commander, and the battle of St Quintin, when he led the English contingent that covered itself in glory.
So Elizabeth grew up a vulnerable teenager in a thug culture. And the reason she is so great, the reason she is so different from her father and her brother and sister, is that she had been on the receiving end.
The result is the most remarkable formation of any monarch in British history. It is as though Prince William had been sent not to Eton but to Wormwood Scrubs. For Elizabeths entire early life was a switchback. She was born to ease, as Princess and inheritrix of England. But her gender was a mistake: she was intended to be a boy, and the letters survive that announced the birth of the Prince, with the word hastily changed into Princess by the addition of a scribbled letter s when this unwelcome object was popped into the cradle designed by Holbein and made by the royal goldsmith.
Her mother, Anne Boleyn, more than compensated by the fine clothes and demonstrative affection she lavished on her daughter. But within three years Anne was divorced and executed. And not only executed but morally rent apart.
The false charges on which she was destroyed were not simply adultery but multiple adultery with five men; and not simply multiple adultery but incest, as one of the men was her brother; and not simply incest but perversion. I didnt know the Latin for French kissing but there it is in the indictment: which lip-smackingly described how first the queen inserted her tongue into the mouth of her natural brother, George Boleyn, Lord Rochford, and how he in turn put his in hers as they kissed lewdly with open mouths.
How could the child of a mother so demonised survive, psychologically, if not physically? But Annes death didnt destroy Elizabeth. Even more remarkably, it did not produce a devotion to her mother such as Mary felt after her mother, Catherine of Aragons, only slightly lesser martyrdom at Henrys hands.
Instead, Elizabeth was devoted to her father. She was her fathers daughter. This phrase was first used about her at the age of six. And it appeared constantly thereafter. For contemporaries had only to use their eyes to see that it was true. She looked like Henry, with her fathers hair, skin-colour, nose and lips (though her eyes were dark and lustrous, like her mothers, and she had her mothers exceptionally long, slender fingers). She had much of Henrys character as well: his intelligence, his force of personality, his eloquence, and his ineffable star-quality that made her, like him, the automatic centre of attention.
But in other, equally important respects, she was different, and self-consciously so. --This text refers to an alternate Hardcover edition.