The same can be said of Martina McBride's eleventh studio album as can be said of its title - it's okay, it's fine, but it's lacking a little in inspiration.
First off, the title. Much has been made of the fact that "Eleven" is Martina's first album with Republic Nashville (after ending her long-time association with RCA), heralding something of a fresh start and new sound. So why then call the album "Eleven", immediately reminding the the listener of the ten other records with the previous label? It does seem a bit daft. It's not that important, but I do think it's indicative of some of the other choices that have been made here.
Namely, the songs. It's hard to put my finger on what's missing, but a number of the songs just aren't very strong. "One Night", the album opener, is upbeat and undeniably catchy, but seems like a watered-down version of the lead single "
Ride" from Martina's previous album. In fact, in places it's more than reminiscent, and seems to borrow both the harmonic structure and melody. Similarly, "I'm Gonna Love You Through It", while worthy in its message and sentiment, is Martina McBride-by-numbers, seemingly written as a 'Martina McBride song' rather than a good song for its own sake. "Marry Me" and "Broken Umbrella", meanwhile, are just uninspired - the musical arrangements are bland, to say the least.
It's not all doom and gloom though - the other half of the album is pretty good. "Summer of Love" and "Always Be This Way" sound like good single material, while "Whatcha Gonna Do", "Long Distance Lullaby" and "When You Love a Sinner" add some needed quality to the second half of the record.
My overriding feeling is that not all of the songs on "Eleven" would have made it on to a Martina album in the past, and this is a strange state of affairs when you consider that Martina herself is sharing the songwriting credits on over half the record. Or maybe that lack of objectivity is the very reason. Either way, I do wonder if the creative team could have taken a little longer to assemble their material. Most of the songs are perfectly fine, and I will enjoy listening to them, but it's hard to believe that it's absolutely the best material that could have been picked. Perhaps this is why the album has charted lower than any other of Martina's since 1997 (though still at no. 4!)
If you're Martina fan, then you should still buy this record, and even think about tracking down the 'deluxe' version, which can be purchased from at least one online retailer in the U.K. (two of the four 'deluxe' tracks, "Ask The Boy" and "I Give It To You", are worth having.) However, if you're just casually interested, it might be worth trying another album first. Martina's previous record, "
Shine", is a better and more cohesive offering, and its singles were rightly more successful.
I do like this album - it's mostly good. But I think it could have benefitted from a bit more thought. Just like that title.....