Four stars because this is an important pioneering work, historically. There are just 2 tracks, 1 per side of the original vinyl,"Under the Mersey Wall" and "No Time or Space". Notably, George was 'assisted' by Bernie Krause (see Beaver & Krause
In A Wild Sanctuary/Gandharva) on "No Time or Space". AMR has it that Krause also created the album art (not a communal effort by the Beatles as suggested elsewhere).
This is more of an experiment in sonic painting rather than anything musical. That was the purpose of Zapple records, to serve as an outlet for personal/avant garde/experimental work. I believe the label was discontinued after this and John's (even harder to listen to) foray into Primal Scream therapy and tapes of poor Yoko's miscarriage
Unfinished Music Vol.2: Life With the Lions.
I recall buying this as a 16 year-old Beatles fan and, admittedly, being confounded and confused. I sort of liked it, as it was new,different and well, weird. I played it a couple of times but it didn't fit with anything I did so it ended up being neatly filed away. I think I preferred the electronic sounds of White Noise -
An Electric Storm, which also came out in 1969. It was more noticeably 'musical' or at least dramatic.
Looking back now, in the context of the development of electronic music, this album has to be re-evaluated in a more positive light and recognised for the pioneering work that it is. I can certainly appreciate this was no throwaway effort or just playing with a new toy; the moog synthesizer could only produce a single note at a time which could not be stored and retrieved. Each note(or sound) was manually set up and generated by laboriously patching connections together and then would need to be recorded for insertion into the final work.
So, I say, "Bravo, George" and thanks again for all you gave the world; from your beautiful songs to groundbreaking electronica to big charity events (Bangla Desh) to Handmade Films (without you there may not have been a Life of Brian!)