"Powerful corrective to Churchill’s claim that before El Alamein there were no victories, and an iconoclastic assault on Montgomery’s reputation as the man solely responsible for turning things round."
"Journalistic account of the war in the desert from beginning to end – no bad thing, given the journalist was perhaps the finest war correspondent of his generation."
"Hemmingway hero, discredited desert war strategist, later IRA sympathiser - a fascinating portrait of a man who paid the price for being cleverer than his contemporaries, and showing it."