18 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
If you develop systems, keep this on your desk!, 12 Mar 2001
By "smith_doug" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Effective Requirements Practices (Information Technology) (Paperback)
As a software engineer, I found Dr. Young's book to be practical and very useful. My project has been implementing six of his ten "Recommended Requirements Practices," and they have indeed proved to be effective, as advertised. The book is organized around the 10 requirements practices, but covers a very wide range of other issues that influence project success - including such diverse topics as project management, team partnering, process definition, and project communication. The book and accompanying CD are loaded with templates and examples; we've reused a couple of them to produce deliverables for our customers.
The book doesn't have lots of "textbook" things like review problems and quizzes; it's much more focused on real-world implementation than some other requirements books (like the ones that are obviously the collected notes from some professor's undergraduate class). There is a glossary, and two good indexes (by author and by subject) that are accurate and at the right level of detail to make the book effective as a reference. The other thing that has kept this book on my ready-reference shelf is the annotated bibliographies - each chapter ends with a list of key references (mostly books and articles), with explanations of why they are significant, what they contain, and URLs for the ones that are available on the web.
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Guidance from a True Practioner, 12 April 2001
By Ivy Hooks - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Effective Requirements Practices (Information Technology) (Paperback)
Dr. Ralph Young has produced a book from a practitioners standpoint. Dr. Young has spent many years working in the world of systems and software engineering and for the last ten years has put great emphasis on requirements. He has developed and refined a process for emerging the real requirements based on research and actual practice. The detailed process flows are those developed by a team of requirements specialists and used repeatedly by Litton PRC to achieve CMM Level 5. You may not be ready to step into all of this on day one, but you will have a road map to follow as you increase your organization's maturity level. Why start at ground level when you can stand on the shoulders of a proven process that is described in detail in this book?
In addition to providing recommendations for best practices, Dr. Young gives the reader a nineteen page bibliography of almost everything written on the subject of requirements. This up-to-date list including many books from 2000, combined with Key References and Suggested Reading for each chapter, will give you the best cross-reference library you can find anywhere and he even provides this on a CD-ROM.
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great Overview of Best Ideas for Managing Requirements., 24 Jan 2002
By Tom Gilb - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Effective Requirements Practices (Information Technology) (Paperback)
This book is a rich up to date source of the best thinking and practices
regarding requirements. It is a systems engineering book, and is rich in the
motivation/organization/process aspects of dealing with requirements
throughout the life cycle. I especially appreciated the rich pointers to
easily accessible websites for referenced material. The author has personal
contact with the best people in the business, and has managed to collate
their experience and advice with his own large scale experiences. This is
not a book on specific methods for expressing requirements. It is a
manager's book. When my son said "Dad I only want you to recommend the best
of what you read", I handed him my copy.