Impossible to praise this book too highly.
For the millions of working tax payers stuck with levels of debt, public and private, it seems impossible to understand how so many of the smartest brains in the western world could have come together to produce a financial crash the like of which the world has never seen.
There are now several published accounts, written at both the personal and the technical level, of the ingenuity and greed with which bankers both in Wall Street and in London devised ever more complicated debt instruments from which enormous levels of apparent profit could be taken. Econned is different. Smith focuses not simply on the king's non-existent new clothes, but on the courtiers. How could so many people have persuaded themselves and each other that financial risk had been eliminated and endless wealth within reach?
The book traces the evolution of the origins of the crash from the end of the second world war to the collapse of the Berlin Wall and on to the completion of financial de-regulation under Clinton. It examines with wit and erudition how Adam Smith's ideas in The Wealth of Nations were cherry-picked and evolved into an ideology which came to dominate university economics departments all over the western world. It turns a baleful eye on the so-called science of economics itself, showing how, as ever more computing power became available, it came to be dominated by models which could never take full account of life as it really happens, and how increasingly it took over political debate, producing, incidentally, the pitiful level of debate in which the current British general election is now being couched.
Smith does not shrink from detailed, expert descriptions either of economic theory or of ever more complicated debt instruments. I can only urge non-technicians like myself to have faith, perhaps skate over ideas, sometimes difficult to grasp at first and go on to enjoy and be profoundly educated by her book. One is constantly astonished and entertained by the sort of nuggets of information and insight which clear and change one's thinking. Did you know, for example, that the Wall Street rating agencies whose AAA AA BBB ratings are locked, by US law into the sort of frantic securities trading which broke the banks have successfully contested litigation over their ratings by claiming their grades are `mere journalistic opinions'? Or enjoy and ponder the Wall Street joke about `trading sardines.' And there's more.
This is a book which should be on the desks of bankers, politicians, journalists, university teachers and every angry, confused or even curious citizen with a will to find out how we came to be in the present mess and what the prospects might be for emerging from it. Only if we can come to understand the extent to which `free market' propaganda has corrupted our understanding can we begin to correct it and find a new way ahead. With Econned Yves Smith has made a major contribution to that.