Richard Holmes is a distinguished military historian, best known for his TV series for the BBC, including "War Walks" and "Wellington: the Iron Duke", as well as for more than a dozen books on various aspects of the history of the British Army. Unusually for an academic, he's also a soldier, of 36 years standing, and is Colonel of the Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment. In summer 2004 the PWRR were sent to southern Iraq. Richard Holmes visited them there, during a period which saw a lot of fierce fighting and one of the regiment's soldiers win the Victoria Cross. He gathered diaries and e-mails from officers and men to compile a first-hand record of their time in Iraq. This book, "on that windswept headland somewhere between journalism and history" as he puts it, is the result.
One of Holmes's great strengths as a military historian is his understanding of, and sympathy for, the private soldier, the ordinary infantryman (and these days also woman) on whom the grand plans of generals and politicians ultimately depend. This comes over in a big way in "Dusty Warriors". In many ways the book is like the soldiers themselves: not macho, not gung-ho, not at all what civilians would expect really, but instead professional, cynical, humorous, searingly honest and grimly realistic. To a demilitarised society like ours where most people have no contact with the military, and no experience of danger, much of the detail will be shocking. But it's how it is. This is a world away from Hollywood and fictional accounts of special forces. This is a real army, our Army, people like us, doing a difficult and dangerous job.
It's also a job that most of the country doesn't even know is being done. Holmes says he wrote this book because the media's coverage of the Army's work in Iraq is so poor. His is not a book about the rights and wrongs of invading Iraq, or of continuing a British presence there now. This is something that the soldiers don't discuss, so for the most part neither does he. He quotes an officer as saying they are "apolitical - but not amoral". He is of course an enthusiastic supporter of the Army as an institution. But he's much too fair, and too good a historian, to pretend that the Army is perfect. He's simply describing what British soldiers are doing, how they're living (and sometimes dying) and what is being done in Iraq in our name, now.
I'm a journalist, the ultimate civilian, and I've never wanted to be a soldier. But I have had the opportunity over the years to see the British Army at close quarters in the Balkans, Sierra Leone, Iraq and elsewhere. And I visited another regiment in the same area of Iraq in 2003. Richard Holmes's book rings totally true. This is as accurate an account of what it's like to serve in the modern British Army as you will find anywhere. And the people who emerge from it are very, very impressive. I can't recommend "Dusty Warriors" highly enough.