In the previous novel,
Shanghai Girls, Pearl and May are forced into arranged marriages, which lead to the sisters living in America. Eventually they find happiness in their new lives, after several traumatic events, but they are accused of spying for Communist China & this tears the family apart.
Pearl and May have been keeping a lot of secrets, and at the end of the first novel, Pearl's daughter Joy makes several discoveries. She becomes furious with her mother and Aunt May, and makes a drastic decision to leave her home.
I was really critical of Pearl's sudden revelations at the end of Shanghai Girls, and I felt that the ending was too blunt; I didn't know that there would be a sequel, but I still think the ending of the first novel could have been written better.
Having ripped on Lisa See over just one part of Shanghai Girls, I felt I should read Dreams of Joy to be fair to the author. Not being a fan, I can honestly say that Dreams of Joy is one of the best novels I have read in 2011. I read it in one sitting, and was so moved by the plights of Pearl and Joy that I have been dreaming about the characters and settings for several nights in a row. I cannot get the imagery out of my head.
Joy finds her biological father, ZG, and goes to the countryside with him, where she works in the fields. It's a culture shock for Joy, but she embraces her new life. Pearl tries to follow Joy's trail, but she is apprehended by the authorities, and must convince them that she is not a traitor or spy. Pearl also hides the fact that she is looking for her American-born daughter. Pearl must confront many ghosts from her past, and Joy must reconcile her ideals with reality.
There are so many strong elements in this book that I don't even know where to begin. I thought switching the POV between Joy and Pearl made the story that more dramatic. Viewing Communist China through Joy's enthusiasm and Pearl's reluctance made me appreciate the differences between their generations, and the cultural contrast between China and the US. The references to their family's recent past (ex: the fight between May and Pearl, and Sam's death) helped refresh my memory of what happened in the first novel, and gave a stand-alone feel to this novel.
Usually, I am not fond of authors who spend too much time describing the settings, but the author did a brilliant job of using the characters to emphasize the dialects of the languages, the distinction of their clothing, and the disparity of living conditions in China. I also dislike author's notes, but I enjoyed reading the note from Lisa See at the end of the book. I appreciate the tremendous amount of research that she put into her writing. In fact, I was inspired to read several non-fiction books about the time period in Dreams of Joy because See's novel offered such a wealth of information about such a controversial era in history. For instance, I had no idea that their bras were confiscated as signs of "Western decadence" upon entering China.
Any reservations that I had about Lisa See's writing have been settled by Dreams of Joy. I think I might have to read some of her other books now.