what do you make of her this year as the main companion. I personally feel that she is the best companion(along with Jack)on the show. she has progressed so much,i liked her in TRB in 2006 but now i love her!!! Tate and Tennant have great chemistry for the show and series 4 is the best!!!!!!!!!
I feel Catherine was given a pretty hard job in that people judged her based on her other work before she even stepped into the TARDIS. Funny how easily people forget that there was a backlash against Billie Piper initially and yet the general media comment since she left was how great she was and how much she is missed.
i hope that she makes a cameo in one of the specials next year,you know just to bump into the Doctor. I'll miss her. But at least David is still the Doctor,so i can't complain. and what a finale!!!! i was stunned:)
The only backlash regarding Rose was amongst the tiny portion of obsessive online fans, who coincidently, no one could give a toss about. She's popular with the majority of viewers, who are joe-public; indeed they are the ones who ultimately count when it comes to their opinion. Two of the episodes she returned for in series 4 received an AI (appreciation index) of 92!
I've loved every single companion, Martha is the lowest on my list, as lovely as she is.
Yeah, I'd love to see Rose in Alt-Land but I think Journeys End was the last we'll ever see of her and Doctor 10.5. In some ways that's good because it means they can't spoil her ending (I'm hoping someone will do a tie-in novel on them or something) -- one Doctor Who magazine said that the Doctor (in a cut scene) gave Rose/10.5 a piece of TARDIS coral so they could grow their own TARDIS and travel in their universe.
Plus I'm sure Steven Moffat dislikes Rose quite a lot.
I hope Donna returns, so they can give her some closure that ending was cruel! Lol.