When on 30th August 1980 episode 1 of the The Leisure Hive went out, regular viewers of Doctor Who were in for a shock. The iconic "journey through the time vortex" title sequence by Bernard Lodge had been replaced with a more formulaic journey through space, seen in countless other sci-fi shows. The haunting theme music by Delia Derbyshire had been replaced by a more twinkly "disco" version by Peter Howell. Then the opening scene on Brighton Beach (the new producer - John Nathan Turner's - town) which pans across a windswept beach of empty deck chairs for nearly 5 minutes with no dialogue. Then we see our eponymous hero- now in a burgundy version of his costume - snoring away in a deck chair. Art imitating reality, this was to set the mood for the whole show.
Worse to come. K9, much loved by younger viewers, is sent off to trundle after a beach ball by Romana (to a horrendously tiny version of "Oh I do like to be Beside the Seaside") and explodes in the English Channel. When Romana retrieves him from the sea, he is a wreck: covered in seaweed and no longer operational.
In just five minutes all of JNT's changes to the production are introduced and the imagery of a snoring Doctor and broken K9 ,in JNT's back yard, provide an ironic metaphor for what the show had now become: a boring, broken snoozathon.
I've struggled to find anything nice to say about this story because it typifies JNT's approach to Doctor Who: it's just terribly dull and boring. Tom looks bored; K9 (and the humour he provided) is absent; and I can't for the life of me make out the "superior production" that people refer to:
- the lighting is terrible throughout this serial, save for a few short scenes
- the costumes of the Fomasi and just as unconvincing as anything seen in the previous season
- the whole production takes place against a backdrop of white sprayed garage doors!
- horrible incidental music that as another review notes: "like an Ultravox B-side". The whole thing screams 1980s, when Doctor Who was meant to be timeless.
Yes there is some beautiful photography in this - the opening panning shot on Brighton Beach is superb, but this really belongs in an art-house movie, not Doctor Who, when you consider there was no dialogue for nearly 5 minutes into the show. There is also a beautiful scene where the Doctor, Romana and Madame Chairman are looking out into the radioactive wasteland that is Argolis and it's beautifully framed and lit.
Tom Baker is fantastic as a much older version of the 4th Doctor - both in his performance and movements but also the make-up which is superb. Again though, an ironic metaphor- he looks like the audience feels - tired and bored.
Changes are not necessarily a bad thing though - the problem here is that JNT misunderstood the show. When he says he "wanted to bring the show into the 1980s" did he really understand the show? He wasn't making a period piece of contemporary television, more a sci-fiction series not of this world. By rooting the music, production techniques and so on so firmly in that era, he rooted the show firmly of that era. Thus later in the season in "State of Decay" set in a quasi-medieval setting - we get the same twinkly synth music and not suitable medieval music for the piece.
JNT removed all the mystery from the series. We no longer have a journey through time for the titles; now a journey in space. We've seen it before in Star Trek, Star Wars and countless other sci-fi shows. The Doctor now wears '?' on his lapels. This didn't make the lead character mysterious; it just made him look like a comic-strip hero. The US shows are always fond of unsubtly identifying their heroes: "look kiddies - can you make out Superman? He's the one with 'S' on his shirt! Can you make out Batman? He's the one with the bat on his shirt!" So we now have "can you make out the Doctor? He's the one with '?' on his shirt!"
JNT also appears to be patronising the younger audience with the use of bright colours throughout this show - a hallmark of his era. Russell T. Davies once said you should never patronise children when making TV for them. JNT misunderstood them, by removing an element they adored (K9 - there was such an outcry that he came back in a pilot for his own show), whilst at the same time making Doctor Who sets look like the Playschool studio.
The restoration of this serial is superb however. A Dolby Digital 5.1 surround mix - the only Tom Baker story to get this treatment -is great in places. The theme music particularly is good as the titles fly out of the screen and the accompanying audio wushes over your head. The scene also of weightless squash is good, as the ball bounces off various walls and reverberates across the surround speakers. Some dialogue is not crystal clear though, as they didn't always have clean audio available.
The picture restoration is superb too - looking probably better now than on transmission. One of the aspects the restoration has allowed the restoration team to revisit is the colour grading, so that the presentation looks more colourful - in line with current production values, rather than the "washed out" colour we were used to in the 1970s/ early 1980s. Of particular note is the new titles sequence, where you can see the stars in all their refracted rainbow glory; the blacks deep black, and the closing white-out explosion, now devoid of any film dirt or noise (something never possible on 1st transmission). 5* for the restoration.
The extras are the best you will ever see for a JNT story I think. With so many new initiatives at once, you have documentaries on the story, costume, music and title sequence. I used to think the titles were done on an early form of super-computer as CGI- not so. Something stunningly simple but effective: a star filter on a camera, travelling towards black card with back-lit pin-holes.
Of particular note is the excellent "A New Beginning" documentary which outlines both the making of this story and the new changes JNT introduced, with interviews with both Tom Baker and JNT included. So many interviewees tread a fine line between saying what they thought of JNT and not wanting to speak ill of the dead:
"John thought that he knew how to put stories together, and actually he didn't. John liked stories that essentially didn't work and had to be worked very hard on to make them work and he didn't like stories that I think would have been quite marvellous, something was lost as a result of that." - Christopher H. Bidmead
"The dog yes... I wanted shot of that" -JNT
"The character of K9... was a great success with the children" - Tom Baker
"John had asked for the new theme to have a 'discotheque' theme" -Peter Howell
"John was unusual as a producer, he was very young, he had not produced before, but his attitude was different from most producers" - June Hudson
The Leisure Hive was the Leisure Dive, and would sadly set the tone for the classic show's last decade.