Imagine that you escape separately from a spaceship. One of you ends up prisoner in a society that mistrusts everything. You are tortured and questioned until you end up giving them they answers they want to hear. Meanwhile, the other person ends up in a peaceful society were everyone lives in Utopia. This is what happens to the Doctor, Compassion and Fitz. However, perhaps the Utopia is not everything that it seems?
The high concepts that sit behind this story are very good and the parts that dealt with this were very enjoyable. However, Dallaire is unable to create a coherent story within the concept and the book ends up being a confusing mess. Once again the 8th Doctor proves that he is one of the best, but even his humour can not save this book from becoming too complicated. An interesting read for lovers of hard science fiction, but many people will just feel confused.