|
|
15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The best reconstructed classic Doctor Who story yet!, 26 Nov 2000
By A Customer
The BBC has finally released all of its surviving material for "The Tenth Planet" on video, including a reconstruction of that lost Holy Grail of missing Doctor Who episodes, the concluding fourth episode. The reconstruction is far better than what we got for "The Ice Warriors"..... To start with, the entire soundtrack has been used, and not just a select few scenes (which is why this package does NOT include a separate CD for episode four's audio). Also, where the telesnap photos and reused stills from previous episodes are not quite enough to make the action understandable, subtitles are scrolled across the bottom of the screen without obscuring any part of the still thanks to an inlay effect. This is much better than the narration present in "The Ice Warriors", and detracts nothing from the mood that "The Tenth Planet" works to convey. The regeneration clip is, of course, included as expected, but the real bonus is the collection of full motion "home-movie" style film clips spread throughout the episode. As these generally focus on William Hartnell's best lines, you really can say that you've seen his last performance as the Doctor after seeing this. Hartnell is by far the best element of this last episode, and makes this video a must for true fans of the series. Many of the elements unique to this first design for the Cybermen have effective, horrific qualities not seen in any other cyber-story. With the soft-cloth design of the face, and dark, haunting eyes in behind, these cybermen appear to be masking leprosy or skin cancer or something, and they cannot speak without sending the chill of being cybernized into those normal humanoids that they intend to "save". Derek Martinus is not the best director Doctor Who had seen up until this point in terms of mastering camera angles and shot sequencing, or in pulling genius performances out of the cast, however, for all of the tangible technical problems with "The Tenth Planet", it manages somehow to surmount this intangibly. A unique atmosphere surrounds it which Martinus must be given much credit for. Anticipation is a key ingredient that grows stronger and stronger as the story unfolds, and with such major concluding events, it does not disappoint. Experienced actor Robert Beatty gives an exceptional performance anyway, probably the best I've ever seen of him anywhere, as if anyone could stop him! William Hartnell works his usual magic whenever the story moves to him, and Michael Craze and David Dodimead put in solid performances as well. This is most certainly one of the most powerful classics of the Doctor Who program, with layers of elements containing hidden significance, making repeat viewing quite rewarding. "Attack of the Cybermen" is also included in this package, in its British format of two 45-minute episodes, whether you still needed to add it to your collection or not. (I didn't.) Even so, "The Tenth Planet" is worth the price of two stories, and "Attack of the Cybermen" is well matched to it. Gerry Davis had fudged up the true origins of the cybermen in his novelizations, but "Attack of the Cybermen" sets the record straight, especially with regards to Telos, neatly vindicating the original tv episodes. While "Attack" is the only season 22 script not to have serious structural problems, it is far from perfect. Apart from the new element of the Cryons, the story spends much time attempting to relive the series' past. However, that essential atmosphere of family exploration is now mostly dysfuntional, as the dialogue focuses far too much on the irritability of most of the characters, few of whom one can be morally proud of. What this story does have going for it is a lot of action, special effects, slight mythological advancement for the series, and a richly layered soundtrack, making it enjoyable nonetheless.
|