Most Helpful Customer Reviews
44 of 44 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
English folklore brought to the 21st century, 26 April 2001
This review is from: A Dictionary of English Folklore (Hardcover)
This book is so interesting and is a must to discover where all of those superstitions, beliefs, traditions and sayings came from! I originally loaned this book out of my local library for research purposes and I read every item listed. It is so interesting and makes you realise how much you are affected by folklore, the little things you say, the superstitions you believe in, it goes on! Folklore surrounds us and is in our everyday life, whether it is me or somebody else and once you are aware of this you mentally take note. Like how many of us believe in Friday the 13th? The book is extremely informative and I would imagine this must be a hard subject to research, folklore being as it is! The book focuses on English folklore which makes it more personal for the English enquirer and it is interesting to see places in the book that you know or have visited and had no idea of the history of folklore attached to them. Although I am using this book for a project, it inevitably became of personal use also, I found myself searching for things like "touch wood" something that I've said, and the meaning is there in the book, and very informative with further links, so you find yourself totally engrossed. As the book is a dictionary it is easy to find what you are looking for, but I read it like a book so discovered many things I knew nothing about. There are entries from Ram Roasting to toothache and from Devil's Dyke to Valentines Day! Subjects to interest everybody. However, due to the reservations made for the book at the library, I have now purchased it through Amazon at a very good price which I think is worth every penny. It is a good reference book and I know I will be checking in this book every now and again when something inspires me to do so, like maybe I want to know why the Morris Dancers are hanging around outside! I also have the Oxford Companion to Fairy Tales by Jack Zipes (research again honest!)which I think is part of a collection in this style of subject matter, and compliments Folklore well. This book too is very informative although I would say much more in depth as the information is from all of the world covering authors, fairy tales and more! Like I said The Oxford Dictionay of English Folklore is a book that will keep you amused for hours!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Worth Its Weight In Corn Dollies!, 21 Oct 2007
This review is from: A Dictionary of English Folklore (Hardcover)
I have read issues of the Folklore journal, and have always been allured by the true origins of folklore, rather than the fanciful relics of ancient practice theories. It's a shame people still believe in this type of theorising whereby one explanation can be stretched to explain everything from corn dollies to the rising price of fish, but hopefully books like this might counterbalance the trend. I find the main culprits are to be found in the fields of neo-paganism, where all too many authors accept & propagate complete rubbish about the past.
This book is an excellent resource of folklore, much of which I have been brought of with or come across. This book has contributed greatly to an understanding of the reasons behind so many things that seem commonplace, such as maypole dancing (which I did as a child at school!), making daisy chains, not stepping on the cracks in pavements etc.
It's one of those books which I tend to flick open, read one entry, refer to another & then find myself wanting to explore the subject further.
One other attraction of this book for me is that it's about my home country. It seems a real shame that so many people in England have completely neglected the vast heritage that resides in the soil of the land that sustains them. This book goes some way to redressing this, and will hopefully re-introucde some our customs back into the popular consciousness.
This book also takes into account the fact that folklore is not dead, it carries on creating itself in the forms of urban legends, rumours etc, and that todays gossip could become tommorows legend.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Outstanding and scholarly reference guide, 6 April 2001
By A Customer - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: A Dictionary of English Folklore (Hardcover)
Don't let the review below mislead you into to thinking that this is a piece of new-age fluff. Though neo-pagans may also get something out of it, "A Dictionary of English Folkore" is a work of serious scholarship and eruditon, compiled by two internationally recognized folklore scholars and published by Oxford University Press. As such, it is best compared to other reference guides published by academic presses (e.g. "The Oxford Dictionary of Saints", "The Concise Dictionary of American History", "The Norton Dictionary of French Literature", etc.), rather than to books on how to perform Wiccan sex magic. Essentially, this is an alphabetical dictionary of English (not British, just English) folklore. The editors use a fairly broad definition of folklore and the 1000+ entries deal with nursery rhymes, fairy tales, folktales and legends, superstitions, holidays, customs, and even folk medicine and folk music and dancing. Topics discussed include: Mother Goose, Robin Hood, wassailing, the tooth fairy, Michaelmas, splitting wishbones, kissing under the mistletoe, and Morris dancing. The folkloric origins of many colloquialisms and other turns of speech (i.e. why is a ne'er-do-well refered to as "the black sheep of the family") are discussed, and there are even entries for a a few modern urban legends as well. The entries are arranged alphabetically rather than thematically (it is a 'dictionary' after all) and tend to be fairly brief (a few sentences to one paragaph long). They do, however, have cross-references to related entries and come with citations so that those seeking more detailed information about a particular item can go find a source that treats it at greater length. This isn't necessarily a book that everyone needs, but it is an *outstanding* reference guide and will be very useful to those interested in English culture, literature, and history. And frankly, even folks who don't really need a reference guide to English folkore will probably still find this a lot of fun to browse though. (The short entries actually make it great for casual 'bathroom reading' as it were). I don't give out five-star reviews lightly, but a well-researched, well-presented reference work like this deserves it.
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Worth it's weight in corn dollies!, 11 Jan 2002
By Mr. M. P. Duffy - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: A Dictionary of English Folklore (Hardcover)
I have read issues of the Folklore journal, and have always been allured by the true origins of folklore, rather than the fanciful relics of ancient practice theories. It's a shame people still believe in this type of theorising whereby one explanation can be stretched to explain everything from corn dollies to the rising price of fish, but hopefully books like this might counterbalance the trend. I find the main culprits are those in the field of withcraft, paganism etc where all too many authors accept & propagate complete rubbish about the past. This book is an excellent resource of folklore, much of which I have been brought of with or come across. This book has contributed greatly to an understanding of the reasons behind so many things that seem commonplace, such as maypole dancing (which I did as a child at school!), making daisy chains, not stepping on the cracks in pavements etc. It's one of those books which I tend to flick open, read one entry, refer to another & then find myself wanting to explore the subject further. One other attraction of this book for me is that it's about my own country. It seems a real shame that so many people in England seem to find other countries so alluring that they completely neglect the vast heritage of their own, turning instead to the East, the Indians etc. This book is a real celebration of our country, and hopefully will bring our customs into the popular consciousness. However, this book also takes into account the fact that folklore is not dead, it carries on creating itself in the forms of urban legends, rumours etc, and that todays gossip could become tommorows legend.
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent, scholarly book of British folklore, 16 Oct 2011
By Dennis Hendrix - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: A Dictionary of English Folklore (Hardcover)
This book has a focus on folk beliefs and customs, but there's plenty of space devoted to children's games, legends, obscure festivals and the various "bugaboos" rumored to haunt the English countryside. Some folklorists are covered, but fortunately don't take up a lot of room. This book is not as deep as some others like the 1,200~ page "Funk and Wagnall's Standard Dictionary of Folklore, Mythology, and Legend" or the 1,000~ page (excluding index) "Facts on File Encyclopedia of World Mythology and Legend" -- although that one has many articles I'd say they're of less depth. What makes this book shine is the focus specifically on Britain and the feel of true scholarship. Also the authors fit a lot of information into well-written articles, occasionally with books of this sort it feels like the authors are filling up space with wordiness instead of facts. I also like how the author references older books, tracing the origin of certain beliefs, superstitions and practices. A good example of this is sin-eating, which he traces to a book from the 1600's. There are ten plates in the center of the book on glossy paper, mostly of various festivals. The bibliography is extensive. Definitely a great book, a little expensive when one compares it to other books available on this topic -- fortunately I found it for $1.50 at a library book sale. Couldn't resist mentioning that!)
|
|
|