William Shawcross's book provides an excellent general overview of some near-forgotten world crises and disasters, easily accessible to those who, like me, have no more knowledge than that gleaned from a twenty minute skim through the daily paper. It does go somewhat deeper than that and is full of personal encounters and thus wholly new information. It is well written and Shawcross has some of Beevor's talent for making a cliffhanger out of history. However, this book is not in the class of Stalingrad; he fails to draw a thread through chapter by chapter - the book is more like a series of individual and entertaining essays on a mass of horrific subjects.
The book is disappointing in its failure to do more, in the end, than criticise and report. I know it is asking a lot of a journo to solve the world's problems but it would have been interesting had Shawcross given us his views on what might have been done to make a real difference, and extracted some conclusions about the errors that led to such terrible disasters. In a sense he does - he kind of concludes that if it was a disaster then it should have been done differently - but that is just 20/20 hindsight dressed up as analysis. William Shawcross is an intelligent and highly experienced man with unique access to the dramatis personae, and I expected more.