3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
"I've Nothing Against Heroes...", 18 Jun 2010
This review is from: Death of a Hero: Captain Robert Nairac, GC and the Undercover War in Northern Ireland (Paperback)
Jack Hawkin's crusty colonel in that fine old British film The League of Gentlemen says "I've nothing against heroes...except that they tend to crook it for other people"...a point of view shared by many. This book details the background, military service and squalid brave end of Captain Nairac, murdered in 1977.
Nairac was from a "posh" English Catholic background and attended Ampleforth (the so-called "Catholic Eton") and Oxford University (he also attended university at Dublin before before joining the Grenadier Guards). That background (and I once had the misfortune to be acquainted with a former Head Boy of Nairac's old school, the father of a girlfriend...) does tend to result in a certain arrogance and indeed hauteur, in Nairac's case accentuated by his prowess as a boxer (he refounded the Oxford Uni. Boxing Club).
Nairac was, despite the superficially very Establishment background, somewhat of an outsider in his life: his father, an eye surgeon, was of French background but born in Mauritius, as was Nairac himself. Nairac was a Roman Catholic in a mainly non-Roman Catholic country, university and regiment. He was, it seems, not entirely within the usual mould of Grenadier Guards officers and after one tour of northern Ireland volunteered for intelligence duties, attached to one of the "detachment" entities which started to grow up in the early-mid-1970's in N. Ireland.
Nairac was therefore also a literally and bureaucratically "detached" Guards officer, a kind of intelligence officer who trained for a while at the then Joint Services training centre at Ashford in Kent but was never a member of the Intelligence Corps as such; likewise, he liaised to a limited extent (not clear to what extent) with MI5/Security Service and MI6/SIS without belonging, it seems, to either; yet, he also worked with the SAS and on occasion he wore their famous beret and cap badge despite having never been an officer of that regiment; neither did he pass SAS Selection (though he seems to have undergone some anti-interrogation courses somewhere.
As the book makes clear, Nairac fell between the cracks of Army organization and was at times a law unto himself, a situation which, together with a natural self-confidence, led him to his death because, when he was captured (it seems, by bad luck as much as anything, rather than by a targeted IRA operation) he had no back-up which would probably have saved him.
There is some suggestion both that Nairac (who had a deep knowledge of Ireland and its people) was working to some agenda of his own and that the IRA was loosely watching him and may well have been aware that he was a bit of a loose cannon in the British set-up. He may even have had a Sidney Reilly-like meeting or two with the IRA, trying to forge links which were also in existence at higher levels (between Adams/McGuinness and the British Government via SIS). The same sort of thing did happen in WW2 between some British officers and agents and their German opponents in Occupied France.
To my mind, Nairac was a hero, but he was a hero of his own generation, very much his own man, like Gordon of Khartoum or Lawrence of Arabia. In other circumstances, Nairac may well have become a lot more famous than he now is. As it is, even his killers commended, at their trials, his courage: Nairac remains a national hero.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Good insight, 19 Jun 2003
This review is from: Death of a Hero: Captain Robert Nairac, GC and the Undercover War in Northern Ireland (Paperback)
No other source has painted the picture of what Northern Ireland in the 1970s was like. Nairac was a fascinating if bizarre character and the only frustrating thing about the book is that we don't know what happened to him or why. But it is a great story that would make a excellent film and adds to one's understanding of the troubles better than any straightforward history book.
I would like the author to update it, if he can gind out more information - but in the meantime this is definitely worth a read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
undercover military operations in Northern Ireland, 21 Oct 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Death of a Hero: Captain Robert Nairac, GC and the Undercover War in Northern Ireland (Paperback)
An interesting read if you want to know more about the intelligence side of the military in Northen Ireland. It seems as if Capaint Nairac went well beyond the call of duty - apparently patrolling in uniform then changing into civvy's and roaming the same area.
However, it seems as if he was passionate about Ireland and this may have led to him taking too many risks.I think he would be pleased to see the latest developments and the efforts to bring 30 years of misery to an end. Another interesting book by the authour on a military theme!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No