Deadwood: Complete HBO Season 1 [2004] [DVD]

 

 

Create your own review

I'm not a western fan. I grew up watching a lot of them with my dad, but aside from the Gunfight at OK Corral, I never really got into them. So I wasn't sure about this, but I thought I'd have a look due to some very positive reviews.

Now this is going to sound a little bit weird, so I apologise... but I'm not sure if I'm glad that I did look. I've had to rate the series 5 stars because I sat glued to every episode in Season 1 and Season 2, so it's undeniably gripping television, very slickly directly, well scripted, and imaginatively filmed, but it's not a pleasant experience. There's nothing uplifting here. This is televisual nihilism. Dark, murky, filthy and frequently horrific. There are some much needed comic moments, due to a cast of very colourful characters, but the base tones here are black, brown and grey.

I have no problem at all with the frequent swearing. I didn't even notice it much, to be honest. Can't really understand why so many people get their knickers in a twist over it. More grisly murders than you can shake a stick at, and they get flustered over the F and C words. Crazy. I did feel a little bit uncomfortable with the feeling I got in a couple of episodes that some scenes of horror were veering very close to gratuitous wallowing, though. Shock for shock's sake. But this was not the norm- just a feeling I got in maybe 2 of the episodes. I'm not usually bothered by explicit material either, but again, an explicit blowjob while a character is giving a soliloquy can smack a little of... well, going out of your way to offend the easily offended. I do like the risk-taking element, though, and the bravery of the concept. Very original, and tastefully pulled off for the most part.

I've no doubt you'll be riveted by this series if you choose to give it a go, but if you're at all of a melancholic, depressive bent, I'm not sure if I should actively recommend it. It's very haunting, and very unsettling in parts. Thought-provoking, most definitely, but I don't think it's something I could watch again, or would want to watch more than once. Is it worth owning on dvd then? I'm not sure, considering you get no extras on the UK edition. I think that extras might have left me with a slightly sweeter taste in my mouth... helped me to appreciate the art behind the production, and sponge away a bit of the bleakness. As it was, I watched all the episodes, then felt that I needed a very long shower. With carbolic soap. And a little counselling. And a holiday. The craft here cannot really be faulted, but the content is very, very heavy. Approach with caution and handle with care.

The Sopranos, Six Feet Under, Curb Your Enthusiasm, The Wire... HBO's resume is bursting with TV goodness. And it's from this network that the latest - some would say best - of the bunch now emerges.

The concept is fairly simple: Gold rush. Old west mining town. Lots of gold. Lots of whoring. Lots of double-crossing and murdering. But the show is so much more than your average 'Cowboys and Injuns'. Deadwood gives out as much as the audience is willing to put in. It is not an easy show to keep up with. The dialogue between the characters is superb, but a bizarre mixture between antiquated and modern colloqualism. But it works. In fact, it is entirely possible to watch the show, have no idea what is going on and on a superficial level, just enjoy watching the beautifully realized characters interacting with one another.

The plot, well-crafted and sometimes frustratingly complex as it is, can usually take a backseat to the other elements of the show - which is hugely impressive and a brave step for a flagship programme such as this. In fact, it seems the writers have gone out of their way to intentionally snub the classical approach to popular TV writing. David Milch, the godlike genius behind NYPD Blue, is probably responsible for this approach, as it can sometimes feel random and disorganised... in other words, more life-like.

You get the impression that the writers and actors love the characters. The show is certainly an ensemble piece as every member of the regular cast pulls their weight. Ian McShane deserves a large amount of the praise for his dispicable, human and ultimately quite likeable portrayal of Gem Saloon brothel owner Al Swearengen. Timothy Olyphant is excellent as the intense ex-Marshal-turned-Hardware-shop-owner Seth Bullock, as is William Sanderson, Brad Dourif, Powers Boothe, Keith Carradine, Paula Macolmson, Kim Dickens, Robin Weigert, etc, etc. Everyone holds their own and really, everyone deserves some kind of award. Even the incidental characters are well acted. EVERYONE is good in it.

One entertainingly bizarre consequence of the writers' affection for their creations is that, every-so-often and quite randomly, Ian McShane might be made to deliver a soliloquy to an inanimate object (like his severed Sioux-head in a box or his stuffed moose) about his difficult upbringing in an oprhanage. Or another character, such as sweaty-palmed Hotel owner E.B. Farnam might wander down the town's thorough-fare and complain to himself about his underappreciated social status. And in this environment of back-stabbing and shifting alliegences, these soliloquies reach Shakespearean heights. In fact Iago himself wouldn't look amiss, propped at the bar in a 10-gallon hat...

The underlying theme of the show is moral ambiguity, placed in the context of the beginnings of modern American history - which was after all founded on an enterprising spirit as much as a purely libertarian ethic. The only certain rule that show follows is that the Good generally have to make way for the Bad and the Ugly. Every character in the show has come to Deadwood - a real town in the South Dakota Black Hills, with a real history that the show is loosely based on - for selfish reasons. And any character that is there for unselfish reasons, suffers.

Whilst I had not understood why people have such a fascination with the Wild West, I think I'm beginning to. Western Mythology is tangible, as it was only just over a century ago that the "wild west" existed. What John Wayne and Clint Eastwood movies failed to make me enthusiastic about, Deadwood achieves in doing so. Deadwood also once again highlights the irritating trend in British television towards creating patronizing kitchen-sink melodrama instead of well thought out and imaginative dramatic storytelling. Take note BBC, ITV, Channel 4: you should be aiming for this level of brilliance.

By all of these DVDs and join me in cursing HBO for cancelling the final season.

Buy this and you hit the motherlode.

A masterclass in screenwriting, beautiful TV cinematography, Shakespearean-like storylines, a clever fusion of fact and fiction, a strong core of characters, top-class acting, and an aura of authenticism make Deadwood S1 a must watch/buy. It's probably the greatest set of 12 episodes in recent TV history: Feed your sci-fi, comedy, Lost and 24 box sets to Woos pigs.

The downsides?
The language is about the fruitiest you'll hear from a TV drama. Not one for listening with mother.
The knowledge that the final season, S4, has been canned in favour of two 2 hour TV movies, is a huge disappointment: HBO have let down all current and potential fans. You'll watch this, S2 and S3 and then think, I've been cheated by HBO. Shot in the back.

Just start with S1 and enjoy the ride while it lasts. Pure gold.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 64 customer reviews...

 

5.0 out of 5 stars Deadwood Season 1
This is brilliant television. Characters are fantastic and acting is superb. Timothy Oliphant and Ian McShane are brilliantly cast. Read more

Published 6 months ago by Alan Mcintyre

4.0 out of 5 stars Compelling for the wrong reasons
A bit strange to watch a series where you hope for most of the characters to get killed!
But considering the European human offal that 'conquered' the Americas, the... Read more

Published 8 months ago by J. Mero

5.0 out of 5 stars Amazing mini series.
Deadwood is a brilliant series, I got through all the episodes in a few days. All the characters in this are well played by the actors.

Published 9 months ago by S.J

4.0 out of 5 stars Deadwood
I'm a reent convert to the western Genre through thanks to films like Unforgiven and Tombstone to name a couple so i was intrigued to see what deadwood would be like (if not a... Read more

Published 10 months ago by Jim Jim

5.0 out of 5 stars A western with attitude.
DEADWOOD has got to be one of the best series ever. Brilliant acting (especially from Ian McShane (yes Lovejoy). Read more

Published 11 months ago by The Power

5.0 out of 5 stars Deadwood: tales from the raw edge ot the pioneering West
We came to Deadwood late in the day, but are now completely hooked. Another HBO series like the Sopranos and the Wire and the same raw grittiness in the plot and story. Read more

Published 13 months ago by J. D. Eckersley

4.0 out of 5 stars Deadwood
Sometimes old, tired genres get a new lease of life, and never more so than in Deadwood. Foul-mouthed, sexed-up, powerful and violent, this HBO series re-imagines the Western... Read more

Published 19 months ago by Jennifertapir

4.0 out of 5 stars Different, Gritty and Fascinating
Chosen purely on the very positive reviews here, Deadwood turned out to be an extremely gritty and probably realistic portayal of life in the real Wild West. Read more

Published 22 months ago by E. Smith

5.0 out of 5 stars Highly addictive
There is absolutely nothing wrong with Deadwood except they should keep making this series until infinity dawns. Read more

Published 23 months ago by Nightwatcher

5.0 out of 5 stars Sometimes i wish we could just hit 'em over the head, rob 'em, and throw their bodies in the creek
There was a recent poll in the Guardian newspaper where their TV critics voted for the 50 'best' ever TV series. Read more

Published on 2 Feb 2010 by A. Willard

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 64 customer reviews...

Search Listmania!