The recordings cover a 20 year or so recording period from the mid fifties and I was expecting to have to make allowances for their age. However, so good is EMI's remastering that one was rarely conscious of the vintage, even with the mono recordings. This may be partly because the recordings seem to focus, perhaps not entirely surprisingly, on the violin, so occasionally in the concertos the orchestra sounds distant if not actually on its on its way home; this means that the versions on these discs would not always be the only example you would want in your collection. But, for all that, what an extraordinary legacy it is.
My vocabulary does not stretch to describing violin tones so suffice it to say that Oistrakh played with a classical understated serenity conveying a sense of 'rightness' that makes many modern virtuosi sound mannered or intrusive.
I can't stop playing these discs even to the point of repeated listening to those works falling outside my rather conservative central European bias and to which I would not previously given the time of day. Revelatory is an over-used word in reviews but for me this collection has been that, even without allowing for the extraordinarily good value for money. If I could, I would give it 6 stars. Don't hesitate; buy it before EMI realise they have got their sums wrong.