The last time I saw John Harvey at a book signing he made a fairly profound comment: he doesn't think of himself as a crime writer but a writer who's books feature a crime. This is quite critical to those who are tempted to try him for the first time. Most crime writers focus on the pathology of the crime and have the hero racing around trying to solve it in a battle of brains. Harvey doesn't: he writes about loss; whether loss of a career, a loved one, a relationship or a life. As such his books are terribly, terribly sad and often not easy reading. The crime is usually, but not always, the source of the loss and as such as his main characters are cops or those connected to the police, criminals and victims but the emphasis is always on the tragedy that results from the crime, not the crime itself.
He writes in complex sentences (and being slightly critical) can meander a little so his works are for those who can curl up on a sofa and really concentrate on the story. As such I've taken my time reading this collection of short stories and only read one or two at a time.
This compilation comprises just about every short story Harvey has written since
Now's the Time: The Complete Resnick Short Stories and includes the novella
Trouble in Mind (Crime Express) It features 4 Resnick short stories spanning about 10 years of Resnick's life plus 7 featuring an ex-met policeman Jack Kiley who's claim to fame was 5 mins of fame as an amateur footballer who scored a hat trick in the FA cup (his loss was the injury that ended the career before it started). Kiley is a character who never quite had enough "meat" for a full novel but allows Harvey to write about his new home (North London) in the same way that he wrote about the underbelly of Nottingham with Resnick.
The Resnicks mostly feature his relationship with stripper Eileen who's played a larger part in some of the novels. These are really ones for the fans as they're more ways of adding extra detail to the novels rather than stories in themselves. In the same way one story covers the moment Frank Elder from
Flesh and Blood found about his wife's infidelity (the loss there being loss of a wife's love). Finally there are a few stories featuring Harvey's great love: 50's Soho and the Jazz scene. In these the loss suffered by the normally un-named musicians are the loss of promising careers to drugs or gang violence.
I don't know North London well but I live in the middle of Resnicks Nottingham and the detail is beyond perfect. Every house, signpost and street in the Nottingham stories is exactly as described. I have no doubt the stories in North London and Soho are just as accurate.
I'd give this collection 5* because as a real fan of John Harvey these short stories all compliment his portfolio of novels. I'd recommend those tempted to try Harvey for the first time try one of his older novels first as a way of getting to know his characters more fully. I can appreciate how new readers might be disappointed by this collection but regular readers of Harvey will love it.