The Pines' last offering, "Tremolo" was a real gem of dusty Americana, although it seems by and large to have slipped under the radar. This new one follows much the same formula, with David Huckfelt and Benson Ramsey's appealingly hushed vocals and crisp playing encased in a beautifully sparkling production. The only problem is that most of the songs are noticeably less memorable this time.
Things start well enough with "Cry, Cry, Crow" that slips effortlessly into an insistently mournful groove and stays there, while the softly shimmering "All The While", all crisp guitars and background echoes, is far and away the best thing on the entire record. It's just a shame there aren't more like it.
The three instrumentals (too many, surely?) "Moonrise, IA", "Losing The Stars" and the banjo-led "Grace Hill" sound more like backing-tracks waiting to have vocals added, rather than standalone pieces. Elsewhere, song structures and rhythms ("If By Morning") already seem overly familiar because of their similarity to previous Pines songs.
At their best, The Pines are an engaging and very moving listening experience. There's nothing wrong here that a few more tightly written songs can't put right, and hopefully they'll address that next time round.