Footnotes would certainly help here - and there are still contemporary histories with authors too lazy or unwilling to provide them. Interpretations differ, out of context use can alter opinion, and the ability to go to source is often invaluable. But it becomes easier to access period details. More information and further reading is only a few clicks away. A name and date will often do. Prebble provides many of those, and spares us ill-informed argument and opinion. Culloden is still the most comprehensive, accessible and readable 'list' of those involved. For further study, it's a starting point, a good first read. For lay-readers, it's an excellent account - brutal and clear though a mite overcrowded, with the impact of a novel. Definitely a must-read, it's good to see it still in print. There are more informative studies now but, for me, this is the classic Culloden text.