I am not particularly a fan of Anderson - I loved Rushmore, but was bored by both The Life Aquatic and The Royal Tenenbaums. I am, however, a fan of good cinema. To me The Darjeeling Limited demonstrates both the beauty and simplicity of the cinematic form, but more than that, it demonstrates potential. It demonstrates what is possible, not only in terms of the creative form, but also what the Hollywood machine; the accountants, backers, producers and studio executives (those outside of the artistic process) are capable of agreeing to finance. This is the real brilliance of this project.
In terms of the actual cinematic experience, the sets, costumes, music, cinematography, dialogue and performances are about as good as I have seen in a LONG while; this is such a very coherent project which is ultimately the antithesis of what the potential viewer can engage with if they head down to their local rental shop. I think this is a film even detractors should watch once, because I sincerely believe that to anyone who watches it, their frame-of-reference will be shifted, altered and expanded. If you hate this film, so-be-it, but you might want to ask yourself why; what underlies that dislike and distaste. Because maybe, just maybe, the films you have been watching thus far in your life have blunted your sensitivities and sensibilities to real Art and real beauty. If you are unable to grasp this film and appreciate it then I would suggest you are lacking in your propensity and capacity to cognize the peripheries of life and Art.